Ethics Bowl: The Debate Where Changing Your Mind Is a Strength – DTH Episode 342 with Matt Deaton
Show Notes
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply)
Most of us learned that debate means picking a side and defending it no matter what. Dr. Matt Deaton has spent the last fifteen years building something different. In Ethics Bowl, teams get a set of real moral dilemmas months ahead of time, work out what they actually think, and then reason through those cases in front of judges and another team. They don’t have to tear the other side down. If the other team makes a great point, they’re expected to say so.
Matt traces the path from a philosophy class that changed his life, to a two-team competition in Knoxville in 2010, to a movement that now runs from middle schools to college campuses to prisons in several states, and abroad as the Ethics Olympiad and Ethics Cup. He and Wilk dig into why performative aggression has taken over our politics, why so many leaders treat changing their minds as weakness, and why Matt calls it the opposite: a sign of moral maturity.
The conversation touches on Braver Angels, where Wilk works, and Mónica Guzmán’s book I Never Thought of It That Way. Mónica is a friend of Wilk’s and a Braver Angels colleague, and her idea that we should pay attention to how people arrive at their views is something Matt plans to carry into his own classroom.
Key Themes
• Assigned sides vs. honest positions. In traditional debate, you’re told to argue for or against and to win by any means. Matt describes judging a high school round in D.C. where intimidation and false confidence carried the day, and why that looks a lot like our politics.
• Changing your mind is maturity, not weakness. Matt pushes back on the idea that admitting a good point or finding a compromise signals surrender. Wilk shares how he stopped trying to change people’s minds and started trying to open them.
• Coming to learn vs. coming to win. Teaching an ethics class the day after Charlie Kirk’s assassination, Matt gave his students room to talk about it. He credited Kirk’s willingness to engage hard issues face to face, while drawing a distinction between a “prove me wrong” posture and the Socratic stance that the one thing we know is that we don’t know everything.
• Every real issue has thoughtful people on both sides. Ethics Bowl case writers present the strongest version of each position. Students come away more humble, not because every view is equally right, but because the people who disagree with them aren’t morons or monsters.
• The caricatures we build. Between partisan media and social media algorithms, it’s easy to turn people we never actually meet into villains. Wilk connects this to his FOG model of fear, outrage, and grievance.
Takeaways
- Listen to understand, not to respond. Treat it as a skill you practice, especially when you’ve been burned by someone on the other side.
- Concede a point when it’s earned. Leading by example won’t convert everyone, but it gives the people who want peace permission to do the same.
- Ask how someone arrived at their view, and ask the same of yourself. Our experiences shape which arguments feel convincing.
- You don’t need to be an Ethics Bowl coach to use this. New case sets come out each fall and spring, each case condensed to a page or two with discussion questions. Teachers, parents, and community groups can bring one into any room.
- Find a competition near you, or start one, at EthicsBowl.org.
About the Matt Deaton, PhD
Dr. Matt Deaton teaches philosophy at Pellissippi State Community College in Knoxville, Tennessee, and coaches Ethics Bowl teams at the college and high school levels. He founded the Tennessee High School Ethics Bowl, co-founded the D.C. Area High School Ethics Bowl, and served as the original Director of Outreach for the National High School Ethics Bowl. He’s an Air Force veteran, a former Presidential Management Fellow, and the author of Ethics in a Nutshell and Ethics Bowl to the Rescue! Saving Democracy by Transforming Debate.
Learn more about and connect with Matt Deaton:
Website: https://mattdeaton.com
Ethics Bowl: https://ethicsbowl.org
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mattdeaton/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/MattDeatonPhD
📰 Allsides.com
We’re all worn out by the F.O.G. that comes with the daily news, but still want to stay informed. AllSides, a company on a mission to break people out of their filter bubbles, offers a daily newsletter called Balanced News Today. It shows top news stories from across the political spectrum so you can get the full picture and feel better about staying informed. Sign up at: allsides.com/dth-news
The world is a better place if we are better people. Be grateful for all you’ve got. Make every day the day that you want it to be!
Please follow the DTH podcast on:
Facebook, Instagram, Twitter(X) , YouTube, Substack
Subscribe to us wherever you enjoy your audio or from our site. Please leave us a rating and feedback on Apple podcasts or other platforms. You can share your thoughts or request Wilk for a speaking engagement on our contact page: DerateTheHate.com/Contact
The Derate The Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels — America’s largest grassroots, cross-partisan organization working toward civic renewal and bridging partisan divides. Learn more: BraverAngels.org
Welcome to the Derate The Hate Podcast!
*The views expressed by Wilk, his guest hosts &/or guests on the Derate The Hate podcast are their own and should not be attributed to any organization they may otherwise be affiliated with.
Show Transcript
Transcript is AI generated and may contain errors
[00:00:00:00] Wilk Wilkinson: The first Tennessee High School Ethics Bowl had just two teams. Knoxville Catholic and the Tennessee School for the deaf. Since then, the idea has spread to high schools, colleges, and even prisons. It's a competition where nobody tells you which side you're on. You're allowed to agree with the other team, and changing your mind counts as a strength. Today we talk about why that matters so much right now. Stick with me. Welcome back, my friends, to the podcast. I'm your host, Wilk Wilkinson. Your blue collar sage calming outrage and helping to navigate a world divided by fog. And those who would spread that fear, outrage and grievance. The Derate the Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels, America's largest grassroots cross partisan organization working to make courageous citizenship the honored norm. This podcast amplifies the mission that we share to foster a more respectful and united America, where we build together across political and societal divides each week, through the power of story, conversation, and connection with incredible guests, we work to build bridges instead of barriers, not to change minds on the issues, but to change how we see one another when we differ. Friends, it really is about bettering the world, one attitude at a time. We did not create the hate, but together we can direct the hate. So be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Share it with a friend and visit Braver angels.org to join the movement to make courageous citizenship the honored norm. Looking for more news and less bias? Visit our great supporting partner all sides.com for balanced news fueled by media bias ratings. Friends. I am so incredibly grateful that you have joined me for another powerful, Derate the Hate episode. Let's get to it. Doctor Matt Deaton didn't grow up around philosophy. His dad was a decent mechanic at Alcoa for 30 years. Matt had heard of Socrates and Aristotle, but he didn't really know the story. And till he wandered into an intro to philosophy class at State in Knoxville, the same school where he teaches today, it showed him that the questions he'd been quietly asking himself, or ones people had been working through for thousands of years. That's a big part of why he spent more than the last 15 years helping grow ethics. Bowl teams aren't assigned to side. They argue what they actually believe. They respond to the other team's best thinking. And if they hear a good reason to change their mind, they're free to do so. Matt founded the Tennessee High School Ethics Bowl, helped launch the D.C. area and national high school competitions, and wrote a book about it, Ethics Bowl to the rescue. Saving democracy by transforming debate. You'll hear braver angels come up along with my friend Monica Guzman book, which Matt's been reading. We get into performative aggression why humility is a civic skill, and how any of us can bring this approach into our own conversations. Let's get into it with my friend Matt Deaton. Here we go. Doctor Matt Deaton. Welcome to the Derate The Hate podcast. It is good to see you today.
[00:03:37:21] Matt Deaton: Thank you Wilk, it’s my pleasure.
[00:03:40:02] Wilk Wilkinson: Yes. It's my pleasure as well. Matt, this is this is going to be a great conversation. I was looking at the work that you've done. You reached out a little while back to introduce me to the Ethics Bowl and and a book you've written, and I'm excited to hear about this. Anytime we're talking about, you know, civility and and and mindset and how we work through complex problems together. I get a little bit excited. It's kind of my thing. And and what you're doing here look so look solid. So, let's first find out a little bit more about you. Matt, I know you're a professor of philosophy at Pellissippi state, but, you're you're also the co-founder of or the founder of Ethics Bowl.
[00:04:28:13] Matt Deaton: I wouldn't say that. No, no, not not the founder of ethics. But I did found the Tennessee High School Ethics bowl, and I co-founded the D.C. Area High School Bowl, and I run EthicsBowl.org. I do lots of different things, but a gentleman named Bob Ladson, who passed away just a few months ago. He's the founder of Antics Bowl. He was from Chicago and has spread through the college ranks in the high school ranks. But I don't want to take more credit than I deserve. All credit to Bob for founding Ethics Bowl.
[00:04:53:04] Wilk Wilkinson: No. That's fantastic, and thank you for the clarification I think it's important to be, you know, clear and accurate and,
[00:04:59:23] Matt Deaton: Much respect to Bob. He, he had a special personality about him that really encouraged people to to to get on board and support and buy an ethics bill. And he he really lived it through his example. So much respect to to Bob and his wife Joanne as well.
[00:05:14:23] Wilk Wilkinson: Fantastic, fantastic. Well, thank you so much for that. And which will lead me to my next question then, Matt, is, is how did you become interested in in ethics bowl? And then ultimately, how did that lead to you writing the book? Ethics Bowl to the rescue. Saving democracy by transforming debate.
[00:05:34:21] Matt Deaton: Well, I was a graduate student studying philosophy at the University of Tennessee, and I was interested in promoting philosophy outside of academia and also to the younger audiences. I'd always thought that if I had been introduced to academic philosophy younger in my life, I could have made different decisions, better decisions. My family didn't really know what academic philosophy was, and you can't blame them. My my father was a diesel mechanic who worked at Alcoa Aluminum for 30 years and retired. My mother was a was a housewife, and I'd heard of the Socrates guy that heard of Aristotle. I really didn't know the story until I stumbled into an intro to philosophy class at Pellissippi State, where I happened to teach today. And when I took that class, I couldn't believe that people had been thinking about and writing about and discussing all these cool topics and asking all these difficult questions that I had had in the back of my mind, and that I had asked friends and mentors informally, I really didn't. I really didn't know or appreciate that there was this huge body of literature. All this progress had been made about all these crazy ideas. And so I wanted to share that with with more young people. That and with the hope that they could also become more thoughtful persons earlier in life. And so I went to a pre-college philosophy interest meeting at the annual Association for Practical Professional Ethics meeting. I think it was in Cincinnati that year. And so I just went into this session. It was just a regular planet. This conference, we went to different sessions on different applied ethics topics. And in this one it was on ideas for promoting pre-college philosophy. And Roberta Israel, off from the Squire Family Foundation, was talking about ethics bowls, I'd never even heard of ethics bowls, but she pitched it as an alternative to traditional debate, one in which the teams weren't told what to think. They were required to attack one another, they were allowed to change their minds, and it simulated the best benefits of the best applied ethics philosophy classroom. But it did it for a younger audience. The idea was that people at this, this conference, could go back to their local communities and possibly found high school ethics bowls, and people were there from all over the country. Well, I happened to be traveling with the UT philosophy to head John Hardwick at the time, and I was very much inspired by this. And so I saw John after the meeting and I said, hey, if you'll fund this through the department, I'll go back to Tennessee and I'll organize it. And he said, all right, Matt, you got a deal. So that went back to you T and recruited some support from my fellow graduate students and reached out to some different high schools. And we held the inaugural Tennessee High School Ethics Bowl. It was a very modest event, and this was in 2010. We had two schools. We had Knoxville Catholic and Tennessee School for the deaf, and those were the only two schools that actually came through for the the actual competition. But it was really fun. I got to be an assistant coach for the Tennessee School for the deaf, go out and work with them some. They gave me a cool sign name. It's just the letter M a next to your head for thinking, okay, but it was a success. They were very much inspired. And so the next year we expanded and we expanded again. And when I left East Tennessee and moved to Washington, D.C. to be a Presidential Management fellow, I turned it over to some UT graduate students, and they continue to organize it today. In fact, I, I competed last year. I took a team of homeschool students, my my, my son and my daughter and a few of their friends and competed in the Tennessee House with Expo. But when I got to D.C., I started working with the Squire Foundation. Even more so, the same lady that had introduced me to Ethics Bowl asked me to be a senior research fellow for the Squire Foundation and to help promote ethics bowls nationwide, and that led to a partnership with the PA center for ethics of the University of North Carolina. And we went to Chapel Hill. We met with some professors there, and we hatched a plan to found a National High School ethics Bowl. So at the same time, I was working with American University in Georgetown University to launch a new D.C. area high school ethics Bowl. And the idea for the National High School Ethics Bowl was, if we can have a national event, this will help the regional organizers all across the country recruit new schools and recruit new teams to tell them, hey, if you participate in this, you got the chance to compete in a national competition. Well, it worked out. The good folks at UNC decided to host. They still hosted today. I've traveled there with the D.C. team and been back another time to see the wonderful competition there. But that's how I got involved. And our main involved as obviously the original director of outreach for the National High School Ethics Bowl. So I would recruit new organizers, typically philosophy professors, ethics professors, and then I would help them a long distance launch their new competitions. In some cases, I would travel on site. I flew out to Los Angeles for the inaugural Southern California High School Ethics hosted by USC. Worked with an amazing young man out there. It was a actually a high school student named Max Mitchell, who was the lead organizer. So typically it's a philosophy professor that organizes. But the person who is most inspired in Southern California to do this was a young man in high school.
[00:10:35:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Fantastic.
[00:10:36:18] Matt Deaton: And so help, help with that event. And if you want this long story to come all the way back to the book. I continue to be involved in ethics, both because it was a way to elevate civic discourse. So not just a way to introduce philosophy to younger audiences, but also to elevate the way that citizens engage with one another. Because I was very disheartened in the way that politics had become more travel, more violent, how both sides were demonizing the other side, how this led to unnecessary violence and hatred and vitriol. The Ethics Bowl was the alternate method. It was a method in which everyone was shown mutual respect. They were invited and encouraged to share good reasons to change their mind, if given good reason to do so, to be humble. And so.
[00:11:24:10] Wilk Wilkinson: And we'll get in. We'll get into that a little bit deeper here in a few minutes. Let's, I want to I want to actually dig right now before we before we get into that piece of it, Matt, I want to I want to dig into the the I guess the finer details of what ethics bowl is and, and what differentiates ethics bowl from, from your standard debate because as I understand that this isn't this isn't necessarily pitching civility as a as an attitude so much as, as. You mentioned, you mentioned the ability to change one's mind and be able to kind of pivot during the thing or that that's my word, not yours. I mean, when I think about when I think about a standard debate and I and I got to be careful here because, there's, your standard kind of high school debate team and the way that debates are often done. And, and then you've got the ridiculousness that political debates have turned into. But then and then you've got like braver angels where, you know, where I obviously work that.
[00:12:36:08] Matt Deaton: I love Braver Angels, big fan.
[00:12:37:17] Wilk Wilkinson: They have a they have an entirely different kind of debate program there that really is about, not so much, you know, the battling back and forth, but actually expressing our different ideas and, and how we've come to understand different things and what is what our, what our experiences are that that led to us believing certain things. But in some debate models, you're expected to actually express the idea of the other side or give the best argument from the other side. What about quiz bowl? Is ethics bowl different than than something somebody might expect from a a standard debate.
[00:13:25:10] Matt Deaton: In a in a standard debate, the teams are going to be told, hey team A, you're for you're for it. Whatever the issue is, hey team B you're against. It doesn't matter what you actually think. This team, you're for it. This team, you're against it. Now when you get in the room, use whatever rhetorical trick you can think of to win the debate. It doesn't matter what you actually think. It doesn't matter if the other team makes a good point. It doesn't matter if the information you're using is not terribly credible. Just do whatever you can use intimidation techniques, use pseudoscience whatever you want. Yell at them, intimidate them in different ways. That's what you see in traditional debates. And the people that we're going to ask traditional debates, they're doing this from a perspective of love. The reason, the reason they're in this is that they want to empower young people. They want to help them conquer public speaking fear. They want to help them become advocates later in life. They want them to learn about public issues and to have that confidence to, to to actually be involved in politics and to be future leaders. So I'm very critical of the traditional debate model, but not of the people involved with traditional debate. My main goal is to recruit them to adopt Ethics Bowl, because with an ethics Bowl model, the teams receive a packet of typically 12 to 15 cases on a variety of topics 3 to 4 months before the event, and those teams work with their coaches and with their team members to figure out what they really think about those various issues. And then when they come to the event, they're not told you're for it, you're against it. They're asked, what do you really think is the best position? And then they're given an opportunity to share their ideas, to share their arguments, to share their reasoning. There's a break and the other team confers, and then they share their analysis of the first team's arguments. They're not required to overly attack them. They're not required to be dismissive. They're not required to prove that the first team is incorrect. In fact, they're allowed to agree with them generally if they want to. If they really think the first team made a fantastic argument, they should say that was a fantastic argument. Almost always, there are going to be different points that teams are going to have some disagreement. If they didn't, that would be superficial. It would be unrealistic. So we expect there to be some disagreement. But the norms are far different than traditional debate. And then the first team is given an opportunity to confer, and then they come back and they provide their response to the commentary from the first team. And then the first team has a direct interaction with the judges. Usually it's a panel of three judges. Usually at least 1 or 2 are applied ethicists, but sometimes there are members from the community, sometimes they're college students. Anyone can be a judge with enough quality training and and the right attitude. But then the role is reverse. And now the second team receives another case so the teams know what the case pool is going to be before ahead of time. But when they go into each round, they don't know what case they're going to talk about. And so that first team, they got a case that they weren't aware of, they got a question they didn't know about. They have to answer it. Then the roles reverse in another case is announced. And that second team does the exact same thing. So in traditional debate I've judged debates. I was asked to judge a high school debate in Washington, D.C., sat there in a classroom, and I watched some pretty heavy intimidation and bullying, saw students pretend as if they really were passionate about a particular perspective. And I felt that this, this performative aggression and this performative performance of the false assurance and false confidence, that's what we oftentimes see in our politics, unfortunately. Yeah. It's I think it's the case that we've been conditioned to think that whatever the leader of our tribe is, they should set the agenda, they should tell us what we should think. And then our job is citizens is to simply defend that view to the death. Whatever it takes, and not not to admit on the other side has any points. But ethics is attempting to encourage humility, encourage conversation and collaboration and ultimately solutions.
[00:17:22:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah, and I love that. And this sounds, you know, now now having had you explain it that way, this sounds a lot more aligned with what a Braver Angels debate is than what your standard debate is. And and I will just be completely honest, I love that a lot more, because the performative aggression thing that you mentioned, Matt, is, is one of the ugliest parts of our politics. And and it has it has taken on a life of its own in many ways in terms of of the way that people win elections and the way that people, just just the way that people conduct themselves on, in, in, in terms of, well, that's my opponent. So I have to do this or, you know, I've, I've heard politicians say, well, well, I do like this person, but I can't publicly express that I like this person because it's a sign of weakness or it's a sign that I'm going to, you know, that I've given in some way to to their side of the argument,
[00:18:35:22] Matt Deaton: A it's a sign of moral maturity. If a person is willing to change their mind, if they acknowledge it, I don't I don't have everything figured out. Hey, maybe we could find a compromise or a solution. My goodness. Why would anyone think that? That's a sign of weakness? To me, that seems to be a sign of sophistication and maturity.
[00:18:52:17] Wilk Wilkinson: Oh, that's absolutely right. And you know, when we think I mean tying this back to Socrates and and you, I know you talk a lot about about Socrates but you know, one of the many things that that many amazing things that were passed down Socrates is the idea that that, you know, I don't mind being refuted if somebody can, you know, bring bring better facts to, to the table, you know, and I don't mind refuting somebody if I have better facts than they have. And we can work together to find the right solution.
[00:19:24:00] Matt Deaton: Which is hard to do in practice because it's natural for humans to tie their ego to their positions, and especially if you've been personally hurt by someone from the other side. It's hard. It's hard to to convince yourself to actually listen to the idea that they might be correct, because if they've been a jerk about it and you've been insulted, you've got this, this egoistic reason to not listen to the reasons and to to simply. And I've been guilty of this as well. I feel that same instinct. I mean, it's not like I'm perfect. It's not like any of us do this perfectly, but it's something to acknowledge and to understand and to overcome because we're better than that. We can definitely overcome that. And I think if if people on one side or the other begin to do that and they lead by example in that way, I think that would encourage others on the other side to to do the same. They may not do so immediately. They may just jump on you immediately and say, I told you I was right. But over time, if we demonstrated that willingness to change our minds, to concede points, that interest in collaborating and moving toward cooperative solutions. I think we could inspire a lot of other people to do it. Not everyone. Of course, there are going to be people that remain tribal. There are main aggressive. Not not everyone wants peace, right. But I think there's a majority of them want peace. And that's what we're speaking to.
[00:20:42:01] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. Well and I think that's hugely important Matt, because There are very large forces at play in whether it be our media ecosystems, our political ecosystems or our social media ecosystems that are very well funded and very much like to keep people divided. I call it the fog model. People use fear, outrage and grievance to to keep us on our heels and keep us, you know, fighting with each other. Yeah, but of course. But what I hear you saying, and I think it's hugely important and it's it's something that I've talked about quite often, is when we listen to people with intention and listen people with an open mind and an open heart, we often find that our own certainties were not probably as well founded as we had originally thought they were. And if we are doing nothing but listening to that other person with the intention to respond rather than the intention to understand, we are missing out on a lot of things, right? I always talk about this. I mean, one of the things when I was politically polarized that I used to do quite often was I when I would engage in an argument, my intention was to change that other person's mind, right? I mean, I wanted to show them that I was right and they were wrong, and we were going to figure out a way to get you onto my side. And I figured out on most cases, that's a it's just an absolute failure. Yeah. So, you know.
[00:22:15:07] Matt Deaton: The rest.
[00:22:15:14] Wilk Wilkinson: Of you try to open I don't try to change people's minds. I try to open people's minds. But amazingly enough, Matt, when you try to open people's mind to the idea that certainty stands in the way of a lot of things, sometimes they change their minds. But the other method doesn't work. Talk about it, right?
[00:22:37:23] Matt Deaton: Yeah. Some students. I was teaching a ethics class the day after Mr. Kirk was assassinated. And rather, rather than just ignoring the news and something that was on the students minds, I decided to have them to talk about it a little bit. I mean, we we discussed things about political advocacy. We discussed political philosophy, different political philosophies in my classroom. And one of the things I was able to respectfully share with the students was that from what I know of Mr. Kirk, which wasn't a whole lot before his assassination, I've looked up a lot of his his interviews since. From what I know from his style, he was very much open to respectful, reasoned discussion. And he was a very good example when it came to a respectfully engaging, a very difficult issues and attempting to do it, and what appeared to be a high brow fashion. The only thing that I would argue against in terms of his style, with all due respect, is simply the fact that his approach was prove me wrong. His approach was I have all the answers. It seemed to be. I mean, I've not watched all of this footage, but from what I've witnessed, he seemed to come to the discussions not wanting to discuss, but instead just simply wanting to win. And so he did it in a more highbrow fashion than we typically see on social media. But it seemed to be a very close minded perspective. And maybe he had very good reason. Maybe he had thought about all these issues very carefully, and he was very confident in them. But the difference between that attitude, which is is quite common, and the attitude that I attempt to to encourage my classroom to through Ethics Bowl is one in which I don't have everything figured out. I mean, the one thing that I don't know is that I don't know everything. One thing that I do know is that I don't know everything. I've got so much more to learn that the the Oracle at Delphi and ancient Athens told Socrates that he was the wisest man in all of Athens, not because he knew everything, but because he knew he didn't know everything. And that's the one thing that he had up on everybody else who thought they knew everything.
[00:24:36:01] Wilk Wilkinson: So that is such a beautiful line. and just that, that train of thinking that that idea that, it's not everything that I know that makes me so wise. It's that I have the ability to understand that I don't know everything, and I am not going to let the what I don't know that I don't know stand in the way of anything that I could possibly then learn. Right.
[00:25:02:22] Matt Deaton: That and the attitude is so rare in our leaders, unfortunately, we have it looks like a courtroom inside a courtroom, having a prosecutor and a defendant that is attempt to prove guilt and innocence that works fine in a courtroom where you have a judge to oversee the procedures and you have a jury that sits back into sides. But in the real world, we're all the judge, we're all the jury, we're all the advocates as well. And so we it's a far more productive model to think about these different issues and discuss them in a truth oriented way, where we attempt to figure out what makes the most sense, and instead we see so many people pretending that they have everything figured out 100%, and everyone that agrees with them is both righteous and correct, and everyone who doesn't agree is both ignorant and evil. But we're we're doing what we can to change that, that attitude. We're doing what our what we can to lead by example, which oftentimes psychologically is not easy. I understand that it's hard to to concede points sometimes, especially when you've been jaded.
[00:26:02:04] Wilk Wilkinson: This is not easy. This is not easy. And that's that's exactly right. There's so many people and and it's this is this is one of those things that, you know, people get burned by bad arguments, people get burned by bad people. And it turns them off to the idea that, you know, argument or conversation is even worthwhile. And and that is a huge, huge problem in society today. And that's why when you when you align yourself or associate yourself with people who who have no. No mechanism in their circle for any kind of dissent or, you know, without being, you know, without, you know, without accusing you of bad faith or whatever. It's just not a healthy environment to be in. I mean, again, going back to the wisdom of Socrates and, and the idea that that we just we have to be able to recognize that there are so many things that we don't know and do not allow that which you don't know, to stand in the way of all the great things that you could end up possibly knowing. I this is this is the, the genesis of of so much wisdom. Because when I talk about us, you know, I talk about our learning and our, our just development as human beings and how we become better human beings. Stepping outside of our comfort zone is a huge part of that. Matt. Stepping outside of our comfort zone and engaging with people, that, number one, that we know that we disagree with. But number two, you know, there's that old line and I, I, I'm blanking on who may have said it at this point, but there's that old line where if you're the smartest person in the room or you believe you're the smartest person in the room, you better find a different room, because.
[00:27:57:04] Matt Deaton: No. You're not growing. You're not learning anything. Yeah.
[00:28:01:20] Wilk Wilkinson: You're not growing. All growth comes outside of your comfort zone, and it can be very, very uncomfortable to know that you're not the smartest person in the room. It can be very, very uncomfortable to know that you're you're the only person in the room with a particular opinion. And there are others that, that, that see things very different than you. But true understanding and true wisdom comes from the idea that we all live through and see the world through different lenses, and we are going to grow from experiencing other people's lens and perception of things.
[00:28:35:01] Matt Deaton: You know, the different lenses. You know, that's something that I hadn't appreciated as much as an academic and as an advocate of ethics as I should. I was recently reading Monica Guzman's book. I never thought of it that way. So she's she's one of the leaders and braver angels.
[00:28:51:07] Wilk Wilkinson: Such a good friend of mine. Yes.
[00:28:52:22] Matt Deaton: Oh, man, I'm such a fan. And one of the things that she's emphasized in her book that I really hadn't thought as much about, or appreciated enough, is that we do need to think about how people arrive at the views that they have, and to the extent that we can reflect on that, we will be more open to considering new perspectives. So as a as an academic and engaging in political philosophy and applied ethics, we're always interested in the arguments. What are the premises? How do they work together to support the conclusions? And are there any logical flaws or any of these premises more or less likely to be true? Is somehow the the logic between the premises and the conclusion not as tight as it could be, even when it's moral arguments, you can evaluate them, but that neglects the fact that people are probably going to be more or less predisposed to bias and give more weight to premises and arguments that align with what they want to believe, and what they want to believe is probably going to be a function of their experiences and what's happened prior in their lives and such. And so if we don't think about that ourselves, if I don't think about that. I'm not going to be in a terribly good position to discuss any of these difficult issues. So that's one thing I want to change inside my Applied Ethics in Philosophy classrooms, based on this wonderful book, and also my approach to being an ethics coach, to make that a part of the discussion as well.
[00:30:08:14] Wilk Wilkinson: Yes. And and yeah, there's a line from, from Monica that is is probably the most quoted line on the podcast here. And I constantly quote her as saying that her and I have appeared together many times and done done a lot of things together. But one of the best lines that Monica Guzman has ever said is those who are underrepresented in our lives will be overrepresented in our minds and our imaginations. And and it goes right to what you're talking about, Matt. And in terms of the lens through which different people see the world and the way that other people see things, if we don't have those folks in our lives, if we don't interact with them, if we don't spend time with those folks, we begin to envision who they are and what they believe and and what their perception of the world is with no true actual account of who that person is or what lens they've been seeing the world through. So they we turn them into some kind of caricature, and instead of knowing what makes them believe what they believe and knowing why they believe what they believe, we then make that up in our own minds. And it's a huge disservice to them and us.
[00:31:22:00] Matt Deaton: And these and these monsters, these fictitious monsters that we make out of the people that disagree with us. It's not something that we do in isolation. It used to be the case that there was talk radio. Then you had the partisan news media, but now with social media algorithms. My goodness. I mean, if you click on the wrong thing or just anything that might have appealed to you at one time, you're going to have that perspective and that stereotype and that caricature reinforced over and over and over. That's going to make it very difficult for you to think of the person who might disagree as being a reasonable human being. Well, I'll tell you, any issue that's an issue has to have thoughtful people on both sides. Otherwise it would not be an issue. I mean.
[00:32:00:02] Wilk Wilkinson: No, that's absolutely right.
[00:32:01:06] Matt Deaton: Everything that's something beautiful about ethics cases is, no matter the issue, whether it has something to do with artificial intelligence in education or if it's an interpersonal issue, or whether it's some sort of a religious issue, a bioethics issue. The case writing committee always represents at least two different perspectives. They never pretend that it's just a one sided. This should be clearly the the conclusion at which you arrive. No, the cases and the issues are selected because they're difficult. And the case writing committee does its very best to present the best position supporting those different, different positions of the best arguments in the most charitable terms possible. And through the process, the students themselves come to be far more humble in their own views because they realize, man, whatever the topic is, they're going to be some smart, reasonable people on both sides of it. That doesn't mean they're equally correct. It just means they're not morons. They're not evil. It means we should talk about it together and figure it out.
[00:32:56:06] Wilk Wilkinson: that's right. And, that's a beautiful thing that, those tools are available, available to the, to the folks that are participating in these. So speaking of books, you brought up Monica Guzman's book. I want to take this last couple of minutes, Matt, and talk about your book, ethics, Bowl to the Rescue Saving Democracy by Transforming Debate. This is obviously, you know, largely centered around Ethics Bowl and your work in ethics. But tell people what they're going to to find in this book, Matt. And then and then we'll finish out by telling people where they can find it.
[00:33:30:05] Matt Deaton: Well, if you're inspired at all, the the possibility of the Ethics Bowl might be able to help elevate democratic discourse, teach moral maturity, humility. For some people, it just doesn't resonate. But if it resonates at all with you, and I suspect many of your audience members will find it resonate, visit EthicsBowl.org. There you can see how you can get connected with a high school competition. With a college competition, it's also being organized on the middle school level. This is something that's a global there's a Ethics Olympiad. Is is just ethics bowl in Australia, China and India. Ethics Cup in the UK is the same thing. It just has a different name. But what you'll find in the book is a lot about the history of Ethics Bowl. Why it's so beneficial while the cases are so cool, one of the cool things about the cases is that they're released on the high school and the college levels every fall and every spring, and they're always contemporary moral issues and political issues, some of the most difficult issues possible, but they're condensed, usually down into 1 to 2 pages and on the high school level to have some discussion questions. And so these are the sorts of things that you don't have to be an official ethics Bowl coach to talk about. Any educator could take a look at the case set and then introduce one of those to most any classroom. There's stuff in there that could relate back to biology, to science, possibly even math, maybe some relation to artificial intelligence there, but definitely social studies, government classes, anything that touches on most anything apart from possibly theoretical mathematics. So but in the book you learn about all that stuff, the history, the fact that ethics polls are practiced in prisons. Friend of mine Count Kyle Robertson took his inter-collegiate ethics team from UC Santa Cruz into San Quentin and held a friendly competition with some students and students there. And some people from Utah happened to be in attendance, and they took at the exposure of prisons back to Utah. A guy in Washington state heard about it and took it to Washington. People in Maryland heard about it and took it to Maryland. The Maryland incarcerated students got so good at it, they wrote a case that was included in the Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl case set a couple of years ago. So it's not an obscure movement like it used to be. It's grown so much since I first started getting involved since Bob Ladenson founded it back in the mid 90s. And if you're a fan of Braver Angels, if you're a fan of Derate the Hate, I think this is the sort of thing that you would love. You don't need to read my book to learn about it. You can just go to the website or just Google Ethics Bowl, but the book will give you a lot of the background.
[00:35:57:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. And I think this is going to resonate with the with the audience. I think that there's there's a lot of good here, Matt, that, that people can find so that the website again is Ethics bowl.org and the book is ethics Bowl to the rescue saving democracy by transforming debate. There's been a fantastic conversation. Again, all these things, all these ways to find out more about you. And this book will be in the show notes. And I do appreciate your time and I appreciate you doing this work, Matt. It's incredibly important. And, and and I'm grateful.
[00:36:30:22] Matt Deaton: My pleasure. Thank you for all you're doing. We're on the same team for sure. Thank you.
[00:36:34:13] Wilk Wilkinson: Friends, I want to thank you so much for tuning in. And if there's anything in this episode that provided exceptional value to you, please make sure to hit that share button. If you haven't done so already, please be sure to subscribe to get the Derate the Hate podcast sent to your email inbox every week. We really are better together. So please take a moment to visit Braver angels.org and consider joining the movement towards civic renewal and bridging our political divide. This is Wilk wrapping up for the week saying get out there. Be kind to one another. Be grateful for everything you've got. And remember it's up to you to make every day the day that you want it to be. With that, my friend, I'm going to back on out of here and we will catch you next week. Take care.
Also Listen
-
Leaving Groupthink: A Former Progressive Operative on Learning to Think for Herself – DTH Episode 341 with Sabrina Joy Stevens
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply) Sabri -
Nothing Is Waste: Turning Tension Into Common Ground – DTH Episode 340 with Derek Richard Thomas and Alizabeth Thomas
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply) Derek -
Why I Won't Tell My Students Who I'm Voting For – DTH Episode 339 with April Chatham-Carpenter
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply) This
Transcript
Transcript is AI generated and may contain errors [00:00:00:00] Wilk Wilkinson: The first Tennessee High School Ethics Bowl had just two teams. Knoxville Catholic and the Tennessee School for the deaf. Since then, the idea has spread to high schools, colleges, and even prisons. It's a competition where nobody tells you which side you're on.
You're allowed to agree with the other team, and changing your mind counts as a strength. Today we talk about why that matters so much right now. Stick with me. Welcome back, my friends, to the podcast.
I'm your host, Wilk Wilkinson. Your blue collar sage calming outrage and helping to navigate a world divided by fog. And those who would spread that fear, outrage and grievance. The Derate the Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels, America's largest grassroots cross partisan organization working to make courageous citizenship the honored norm.
This podcast amplifies the mission that we share to foster a more respectful and united America, where we build together across political and societal divides each week, through the power of story, conversation, and connection with incredible guests, we work to build bridges instead of barriers, not to change minds on the issues, but to change how we see one another when we differ. Friends, it really is about bettering the world, one attitude at a time. We did not create the hate, but together we can direct the hate. So be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
Share it with a friend and visit Braver angels.org to join the movement to make courageous citizenship the honored norm. Looking for more news and less bias? Visit our great supporting partner all sides.com for balanced news fueled by media bias ratings. Friends.
I am so incredibly grateful that you have joined me for another powerful, Derate the Hate episode. Let's get to it. Doctor Matt Deaton didn't grow up around philosophy. His dad was a decent mechanic at Alcoa for 30 years.
Matt had heard of Socrates and Aristotle, but he didn't really know the story. And till he wandered into an intro to philosophy class at State in Knoxville, the same school where he teaches today, it showed him that the questions he'd been quietly asking himself, or ones people had been working through for thousands of years. That's a big part of why he spent more than the last 15 years helping grow ethics. Bowl teams aren't assigned to side.
They argue what they actually believe. They respond to the other team's best thinking. And if they hear a good reason to change their mind, they're free to do so. Matt founded the Tennessee High School Ethics Bowl, helped launch the D.C.
area and national high school competitions, and wrote a book about it, Ethics Bowl to the rescue. Saving democracy by transforming debate. You'll hear braver angels come up along with my friend Monica Guzman book, which Matt's been reading. We get into performative aggression why humility is a civic skill, and how any of us can bring this approach into our own conversations.
Let's get into it with my friend Matt Deaton. Here we go. Doctor Matt Deaton. Welcome to the Derate The Hate podcast.
It is good to see you today. [00:03:37:21] Matt Deaton: Thank you Wilk, it’s my pleasure. [00:03:40:02] Wilk Wilkinson: Yes. It's my pleasure as well.
Matt, this is this is going to be a great conversation. I was looking at the work that you've done. You reached out a little while back to introduce me to the Ethics Bowl and and a book you've written, and I'm excited to hear about this. Anytime we're talking about, you know, civility and and and mindset and how we work through complex problems together.
I get a little bit excited. It's kind of my thing. And and what you're doing here look so look solid. So, let's first find out a little bit more about you.
Matt, I know you're a professor of philosophy at Pellissippi state, but, you're you're also the co-founder of or the founder of Ethics Bowl. [00:04:28:13] Matt Deaton: I wouldn't say that. No, no, not not the founder of ethics. But I did found the Tennessee High School Ethics bowl, and I co-founded the D.C.
Area High School Bowl, and I run EthicsBowl.org. I do lots of different things, but a gentleman named Bob Ladson, who passed away just a few months ago. He's the founder of Antics Bowl. He was from Chicago and has spread through the college ranks in the high school ranks.
But I don't want to take more credit than I deserve. All credit to Bob for founding Ethics Bowl. [00:04:53:04] Wilk Wilkinson: No. That's fantastic, and thank you for the clarification I think it's important to be, you know, clear and accurate and, [00:04:59:23] Matt Deaton: Much respect to Bob.
He, he had a special personality about him that really encouraged people to to to get on board and support and buy an ethics bill. And he he really lived it through his example. So much respect to to Bob and his wife Joanne as well. [00:05:14:23] Wilk Wilkinson: Fantastic, fantastic.
Well, thank you so much for that. And which will lead me to my next question then, Matt, is, is how did you become interested in in ethics bowl? And then ultimately, how did that lead to you writing the book? Ethics Bowl to the rescue.
Saving democracy by transforming debate. [00:05:34:21] Matt Deaton: Well, I was a graduate student studying philosophy at the University of Tennessee, and I was interested in promoting philosophy outside of academia and also to the younger audiences. I'd always thought that if I had been introduced to academic philosophy younger in my life, I could have made different decisions, better decisions. My family didn't really know what academic philosophy was, and you can't blame them.
My my father was a diesel mechanic who worked at Alcoa Aluminum for 30 years and retired. My mother was a was a housewife, and I'd heard of the Socrates guy that heard of Aristotle. I really didn't know the story until I stumbled into an intro to philosophy class at Pellissippi State, where I happened to teach today. And when I took that class, I couldn't believe that people had been thinking about and writing about and discussing all these cool topics and asking all these difficult questions that I had had in the back of my mind, and that I had asked friends and mentors informally, I really didn't.
I really didn't know or appreciate that there was this huge body of literature. All this progress had been made about all these crazy ideas. And so I wanted to share that with with more young people. That and with the hope that they could also become more thoughtful persons earlier in life.
And so I went to a pre-college philosophy interest meeting at the annual Association for Practical Professional Ethics meeting. I think it was in Cincinnati that year. And so I just went into this session. It was just a regular planet.
This conference, we went to different sessions on different applied ethics topics. And in this one it was on ideas for promoting pre-college philosophy. And Roberta Israel, off from the Squire Family Foundation, was talking about ethics bowls, I'd never even heard of ethics bowls, but she pitched it as an alternative to traditional debate, one in which the teams weren't told what to think. They were required to attack one another, they were allowed to change their minds, and it simulated the best benefits of the best applied ethics philosophy classroom.
But it did it for a younger audience. The idea was that people at this, this conference, could go back to their local communities and possibly found high school ethics bowls, and people were there from all over the country. Well, I happened to be traveling with the UT philosophy to head John Hardwick at the time, and I was very much inspired by this. And so I saw John after the meeting and I said, hey, if you'll fund this through the department, I'll go back to Tennessee and I'll organize it.
And he said, all right, Matt, you got a deal. So that went back to you T and recruited some support from my fellow graduate students and reached out to some different high schools. And we held the inaugural Tennessee High School Ethics Bowl. It was a very modest event, and this was in 2010.
We had two schools. We had Knoxville Catholic and Tennessee School for the deaf, and those were the only two schools that actually came through for the the actual competition. But it was really fun. I got to be an assistant coach for the Tennessee School for the deaf, go out and work with them some.
They gave me a cool sign name. It's just the letter M a next to your head for thinking, okay, but it was a success. They were very much inspired. And so the next year we expanded and we expanded again.
And when I left East Tennessee and moved to Washington, D.C. to be a Presidential Management fellow, I turned it over to some UT graduate students, and they continue to organize it today. In fact, I, I competed last year. I took a team of homeschool students, my my, my son and my daughter and a few of their friends and competed in the Tennessee House with Expo.
But when I got to D.C., I started working with the Squire Foundation. Even more so, the same lady that had introduced me to Ethics Bowl asked me to be a senior research fellow for the Squire Foundation and to help promote ethics bowls nationwide, and that led to a partnership with the PA center for ethics of the University of North Carolina. And we went to Chapel Hill. We met with some professors there, and we hatched a plan to found a National High School ethics Bowl.
So at the same time, I was working with American University in Georgetown University to launch a new D.C. area high school ethics Bowl. And the idea for the National High School Ethics Bowl was, if we can have a national event, this will help the regional organizers all across the country recruit new schools and recruit new teams to tell them, hey, if you participate in this, you got the chance to compete in a national competition. Well, it worked out.
The good folks at UNC decided to host. They still hosted today. I've traveled there with the D.C. team and been back another time to see the wonderful competition there.
But that's how I got involved. And our main involved as obviously the original director of outreach for the National High School Ethics Bowl. So I would recruit new organizers, typically philosophy professors, ethics professors, and then I would help them a long distance launch their new competitions. In some cases, I would travel on site.
I flew out to Los Angeles for the inaugural Southern California High School Ethics hosted by USC. Worked with an amazing young man out there. It was a actually a high school student named Max Mitchell, who was the lead organizer. So typically it's a philosophy professor that organizes.
But the person who is most inspired in Southern California to do this was a young man in high school. [00:10:35:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Fantastic. [00:10:36:18] Matt Deaton: And so help, help with that event. And if you want this long story to come all the way back to the book.
I continue to be involved in ethics, both because it was a way to elevate civic discourse. So not just a way to introduce philosophy to younger audiences, but also to elevate the way that citizens engage with one another. Because I was very disheartened in the way that politics had become more travel, more violent, how both sides were demonizing the other side, how this led to unnecessary violence and hatred and vitriol. The Ethics Bowl was the alternate method.
It was a method in which everyone was shown mutual respect. They were invited and encouraged to share good reasons to change their mind, if given good reason to do so, to be humble. And so. [00:11:24:10] Wilk Wilkinson: And we'll get in.
We'll get into that a little bit deeper here in a few minutes. Let's, I want to I want to actually dig right now before we before we get into that piece of it, Matt, I want to I want to dig into the the I guess the finer details of what ethics bowl is and, and what differentiates ethics bowl from, from your standard debate because as I understand that this isn't this isn't necessarily pitching civility as a as an attitude so much as, as. You mentioned, you mentioned the ability to change one's mind and be able to kind of pivot during the thing or that that's my word, not yours. I mean, when I think about when I think about a standard debate and I and I got to be careful here because, there's, your standard kind of high school debate team and the way that debates are often done.
And, and then you've got the ridiculousness that political debates have turned into. But then and then you've got like braver angels where, you know, where I obviously work that. [00:12:36:08] Matt Deaton: I love Braver Angels, big fan. [00:12:37:17] Wilk Wilkinson: They have a they have an entirely different kind of debate program there that really is about, not so much, you know, the battling back and forth, but actually expressing our different ideas and, and how we've come to understand different things and what is what our, what our experiences are that that led to us believing certain things.
But in some debate models, you're expected to actually express the idea of the other side or give the best argument from the other side. What about quiz bowl? Is ethics bowl different than than something somebody might expect from a a standard debate. [00:13:25:10] Matt Deaton: In a in a standard debate, the teams are going to be told, hey team A, you're for you're for it.
Whatever the issue is, hey team B you're against. It doesn't matter what you actually think. This team, you're for it. This team, you're against it.
Now when you get in the room, use whatever rhetorical trick you can think of to win the debate. It doesn't matter what you actually think. It doesn't matter if the other team makes a good point. It doesn't matter if the information you're using is not terribly credible.
Just do whatever you can use intimidation techniques, use pseudoscience whatever you want. Yell at them, intimidate them in different ways. That's what you see in traditional debates. And the people that we're going to ask traditional debates, they're doing this from a perspective of love.
The reason, the reason they're in this is that they want to empower young people. They want to help them conquer public speaking fear. They want to help them become advocates later in life. They want them to learn about public issues and to have that confidence to, to to actually be involved in politics and to be future leaders.
So I'm very critical of the traditional debate model, but not of the people involved with traditional debate. My main goal is to recruit them to adopt Ethics Bowl, because with an ethics Bowl model, the teams receive a packet of typically 12 to 15 cases on a variety of topics 3 to 4 months before the event, and those teams work with their coaches and with their team members to figure out what they really think about those various issues. And then when they come to the event, they're not told you're for it, you're against it. They're asked, what do you really think is the best position?
And then they're given an opportunity to share their ideas, to share their arguments, to share their reasoning. There's a break and the other team confers, and then they share their analysis of the first team's arguments. They're not required to overly attack them. They're not required to be dismissive.
They're not required to prove that the first team is incorrect. In fact, they're allowed to agree with them generally if they want to. If they really think the first team made a fantastic argument, they should say that was a fantastic argument. Almost always, there are going to be different points that teams are going to have some disagreement.
If they didn't, that would be superficial. It would be unrealistic. So we expect there to be some disagreement. But the norms are far different than traditional debate.
And then the first team is given an opportunity to confer, and then they come back and they provide their response to the commentary from the first team. And then the first team has a direct interaction with the judges. Usually it's a panel of three judges. Usually at least 1 or 2 are applied ethicists, but sometimes there are members from the community, sometimes they're college students.
Anyone can be a judge with enough quality training and and the right attitude. But then the role is reverse. And now the second team receives another case so the teams know what the case pool is going to be before ahead of time. But when they go into each round, they don't know what case they're going to talk about.
And so that first team, they got a case that they weren't aware of, they got a question they didn't know about. They have to answer it. Then the roles reverse in another case is announced. And that second team does the exact same thing.
So in traditional debate I've judged debates. I was asked to judge a high school debate in Washington, D.C., sat there in a classroom, and I watched some pretty heavy intimidation and bullying, saw students pretend as if they really were passionate about a particular perspective. And I felt that this, this performative aggression and this performative performance of the false assurance and false confidence, that's what we oftentimes see in our politics, unfortunately. Yeah.
It's I think it's the case that we've been conditioned to think that whatever the leader of our tribe is, they should set the agenda, they should tell us what we should think. And then our job is citizens is to simply defend that view to the death. Whatever it takes, and not not to admit on the other side has any points. But ethics is attempting to encourage humility, encourage conversation and collaboration and ultimately solutions.
[00:17:22:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah, and I love that. And this sounds, you know, now now having had you explain it that way, this sounds a lot more aligned with what a Braver Angels debate is than what your standard debate is. And and I will just be completely honest, I love that a lot more, because the performative aggression thing that you mentioned, Matt, is, is one of the ugliest parts of our politics. And and it has it has taken on a life of its own in many ways in terms of of the way that people win elections and the way that people, just just the way that people conduct themselves on, in, in, in terms of, well, that's my opponent.
So I have to do this or, you know, I've, I've heard politicians say, well, well, I do like this person, but I can't publicly express that I like this person because it's a sign of weakness or it's a sign that I'm going to, you know, that I've given in some way to to their side of the argument, [00:18:35:22] Matt Deaton: A it's a sign of moral maturity. If a person is willing to change their mind, if they acknowledge it, I don't I don't have everything figured out. Hey, maybe we could find a compromise or a solution. My goodness.
Why would anyone think that? That's a sign of weakness? To me, that seems to be a sign of sophistication and maturity. [00:18:52:17] Wilk Wilkinson: Oh, that's absolutely right.
And you know, when we think I mean tying this back to Socrates and and you, I know you talk a lot about about Socrates but you know, one of the many things that that many amazing things that were passed down Socrates is the idea that that, you know, I don't mind being refuted if somebody can, you know, bring bring better facts to, to the table, you know, and I don't mind refuting somebody if I have better facts than they have. And we can work together to find the right solution. [00:19:24:00] Matt Deaton: Which is hard to do in practice because it's natural for humans to tie their ego to their positions, and especially if you've been personally hurt by someone from the other side. It's hard.
It's hard to to convince yourself to actually listen to the idea that they might be correct, because if they've been a jerk about it and you've been insulted, you've got this, this egoistic reason to not listen to the reasons and to to simply. And I've been guilty of this as well. I feel that same instinct. I mean, it's not like I'm perfect.
It's not like any of us do this perfectly, but it's something to acknowledge and to understand and to overcome because we're better than that. We can definitely overcome that. And I think if if people on one side or the other begin to do that and they lead by example in that way, I think that would encourage others on the other side to to do the same. They may not do so immediately.
They may just jump on you immediately and say, I told you I was right. But over time, if we demonstrated that willingness to change our minds, to concede points, that interest in collaborating and moving toward cooperative solutions. I think we could inspire a lot of other people to do it. Not everyone.
Of course, there are going to be people that remain tribal. There are main aggressive. Not not everyone wants peace, right. But I think there's a majority of them want peace.
And that's what we're speaking to. [00:20:42:01] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. Well and I think that's hugely important Matt, because There are very large forces at play in whether it be our media ecosystems, our political ecosystems or our social media ecosystems that are very well funded and very much like to keep people divided. I call it the fog model.
People use fear, outrage and grievance to to keep us on our heels and keep us, you know, fighting with each other. Yeah, but of course. But what I hear you saying, and I think it's hugely important and it's it's something that I've talked about quite often, is when we listen to people with intention and listen people with an open mind and an open heart, we often find that our own certainties were not probably as well founded as we had originally thought they were. And if we are doing nothing but listening to that other person with the intention to respond rather than the intention to understand, we are missing out on a lot of things, right?
I always talk about this. I mean, one of the things when I was politically polarized that I used to do quite often was I when I would engage in an argument, my intention was to change that other person's mind, right? I mean, I wanted to show them that I was right and they were wrong, and we were going to figure out a way to get you onto my side. And I figured out on most cases, that's a it's just an absolute failure.
Yeah. So, you know. [00:22:15:07] Matt Deaton: The rest. [00:22:15:14] Wilk Wilkinson: Of you try to open I don't try to change people's minds.
I try to open people's minds. But amazingly enough, Matt, when you try to open people's mind to the idea that certainty stands in the way of a lot of things, sometimes they change their minds. But the other method doesn't work. Talk about it, right?
[00:22:37:23] Matt Deaton: Yeah. Some students. I was teaching a ethics class the day after Mr. Kirk was assassinated.
And rather, rather than just ignoring the news and something that was on the students minds, I decided to have them to talk about it a little bit. I mean, we we discussed things about political advocacy. We discussed political philosophy, different political philosophies in my classroom. And one of the things I was able to respectfully share with the students was that from what I know of Mr.
Kirk, which wasn't a whole lot before his assassination, I've looked up a lot of his his interviews since. From what I know from his style, he was very much open to respectful, reasoned discussion. And he was a very good example when it came to a respectfully engaging, a very difficult issues and attempting to do it, and what appeared to be a high brow fashion. The only thing that I would argue against in terms of his style, with all due respect, is simply the fact that his approach was prove me wrong.
His approach was I have all the answers. It seemed to be. I mean, I've not watched all of this footage, but from what I've witnessed, he seemed to come to the discussions not wanting to discuss, but instead just simply wanting to win. And so he did it in a more highbrow fashion than we typically see on social media.
But it seemed to be a very close minded perspective. And maybe he had very good reason. Maybe he had thought about all these issues very carefully, and he was very confident in them. But the difference between that attitude, which is is quite common, and the attitude that I attempt to to encourage my classroom to through Ethics Bowl is one in which I don't have everything figured out.
I mean, the one thing that I don't know is that I don't know everything. One thing that I do know is that I don't know everything. I've got so much more to learn that the the Oracle at Delphi and ancient Athens told Socrates that he was the wisest man in all of Athens, not because he knew everything, but because he knew he didn't know everything. And that's the one thing that he had up on everybody else who thought they knew everything.
[00:24:36:01] Wilk Wilkinson: So that is such a beautiful line. and just that, that train of thinking that that idea that, it's not everything that I know that makes me so wise. It's that I have the ability to understand that I don't know everything, and I am not going to let the what I don't know that I don't know stand in the way of anything that I could possibly then learn. Right.
[00:25:02:22] Matt Deaton: That and the attitude is so rare in our leaders, unfortunately, we have it looks like a courtroom inside a courtroom, having a prosecutor and a defendant that is attempt to prove guilt and innocence that works fine in a courtroom where you have a judge to oversee the procedures and you have a jury that sits back into sides. But in the real world, we're all the judge, we're all the jury, we're all the advocates as well. And so we it's a far more productive model to think about these different issues and discuss them in a truth oriented way, where we attempt to figure out what makes the most sense, and instead we see so many people pretending that they have everything figured out 100%, and everyone that agrees with them is both righteous and correct, and everyone who doesn't agree is both ignorant and evil. But we're we're doing what we can to change that, that attitude.
We're doing what our what we can to lead by example, which oftentimes psychologically is not easy. I understand that it's hard to to concede points sometimes, especially when you've been jaded. [00:26:02:04] Wilk Wilkinson: This is not easy. This is not easy.
And that's that's exactly right. There's so many people and and it's this is this is one of those things that, you know, people get burned by bad arguments, people get burned by bad people. And it turns them off to the idea that, you know, argument or conversation is even worthwhile. And and that is a huge, huge problem in society today.
And that's why when you when you align yourself or associate yourself with people who who have no. No mechanism in their circle for any kind of dissent or, you know, without being, you know, without, you know, without accusing you of bad faith or whatever. It's just not a healthy environment to be in. I mean, again, going back to the wisdom of Socrates and, and the idea that that we just we have to be able to recognize that there are so many things that we don't know and do not allow that which you don't know, to stand in the way of all the great things that you could end up possibly knowing.
I this is this is the, the genesis of of so much wisdom. Because when I talk about us, you know, I talk about our learning and our, our just development as human beings and how we become better human beings. Stepping outside of our comfort zone is a huge part of that. Matt.
Stepping outside of our comfort zone and engaging with people, that, number one, that we know that we disagree with. But number two, you know, there's that old line and I, I, I'm blanking on who may have said it at this point, but there's that old line where if you're the smartest person in the room or you believe you're the smartest person in the room, you better find a different room, because. [00:27:57:04] Matt Deaton: No. You're not growing.
You're not learning anything. Yeah. [00:28:01:20] Wilk Wilkinson: You're not growing. All growth comes outside of your comfort zone, and it can be very, very uncomfortable to know that you're not the smartest person in the room.
It can be very, very uncomfortable to know that you're you're the only person in the room with a particular opinion. And there are others that, that, that see things very different than you. But true understanding and true wisdom comes from the idea that we all live through and see the world through different lenses, and we are going to grow from experiencing other people's lens and perception of things. [00:28:35:01] Matt Deaton: You know, the different lenses.
You know, that's something that I hadn't appreciated as much as an academic and as an advocate of ethics as I should. I was recently reading Monica Guzman's book. I never thought of it that way. So she's she's one of the leaders and braver angels.
[00:28:51:07] Wilk Wilkinson: Such a good friend of mine. Yes. [00:28:52:22] Matt Deaton: Oh, man, I'm such a fan. And one of the things that she's emphasized in her book that I really hadn't thought as much about, or appreciated enough, is that we do need to think about how people arrive at the views that they have, and to the extent that we can reflect on that, we will be more open to considering new perspectives.
So as a as an academic and engaging in political philosophy and applied ethics, we're always interested in the arguments. What are the premises? How do they work together to support the conclusions? And are there any logical flaws or any of these premises more or less likely to be true?
Is somehow the the logic between the premises and the conclusion not as tight as it could be, even when it's moral arguments, you can evaluate them, but that neglects the fact that people are probably going to be more or less predisposed to bias and give more weight to premises and arguments that align with what they want to believe, and what they want to believe is probably going to be a function of their experiences and what's happened prior in their lives and such. And so if we don't think about that ourselves, if I don't think about that. I'm not going to be in a terribly good position to discuss any of these difficult issues. So that's one thing I want to change inside my Applied Ethics in Philosophy classrooms, based on this wonderful book, and also my approach to being an ethics coach, to make that a part of the discussion as well.
[00:30:08:14] Wilk Wilkinson: Yes. And and yeah, there's a line from, from Monica that is is probably the most quoted line on the podcast here. And I constantly quote her as saying that her and I have appeared together many times and done done a lot of things together. But one of the best lines that Monica Guzman has ever said is those who are underrepresented in our lives will be overrepresented in our minds and our imaginations.
And and it goes right to what you're talking about, Matt. And in terms of the lens through which different people see the world and the way that other people see things, if we don't have those folks in our lives, if we don't interact with them, if we don't spend time with those folks, we begin to envision who they are and what they believe and and what their perception of the world is with no true actual account of who that person is or what lens they've been seeing the world through. So they we turn them into some kind of caricature, and instead of knowing what makes them believe what they believe and knowing why they believe what they believe, we then make that up in our own minds. And it's a huge disservice to them and us.
[00:31:22:00] Matt Deaton: And these and these monsters, these fictitious monsters that we make out of the people that disagree with us. It's not something that we do in isolation. It used to be the case that there was talk radio. Then you had the partisan news media, but now with social media algorithms.
My goodness. I mean, if you click on the wrong thing or just anything that might have appealed to you at one time, you're going to have that perspective and that stereotype and that caricature reinforced over and over and over. That's going to make it very difficult for you to think of the person who might disagree as being a reasonable human being. Well, I'll tell you, any issue that's an issue has to have thoughtful people on both sides.
Otherwise it would not be an issue. I mean. [00:32:00:02] Wilk Wilkinson: No, that's absolutely right. [00:32:01:06] Matt Deaton: Everything that's something beautiful about ethics cases is, no matter the issue, whether it has something to do with artificial intelligence in education or if it's an interpersonal issue, or whether it's some sort of a religious issue, a bioethics issue.
The case writing committee always represents at least two different perspectives. They never pretend that it's just a one sided. This should be clearly the the conclusion at which you arrive. No, the cases and the issues are selected because they're difficult.
And the case writing committee does its very best to present the best position supporting those different, different positions of the best arguments in the most charitable terms possible. And through the process, the students themselves come to be far more humble in their own views because they realize, man, whatever the topic is, they're going to be some smart, reasonable people on both sides of it. That doesn't mean they're equally correct. It just means they're not morons.
They're not evil. It means we should talk about it together and figure it out. [00:32:56:06] Wilk Wilkinson: that's right. And, that's a beautiful thing that, those tools are available, available to the, to the folks that are participating in these.
So speaking of books, you brought up Monica Guzman's book. I want to take this last couple of minutes, Matt, and talk about your book, ethics, Bowl to the Rescue Saving Democracy by Transforming Debate. This is obviously, you know, largely centered around Ethics Bowl and your work in ethics. But tell people what they're going to to find in this book, Matt.
And then and then we'll finish out by telling people where they can find it. [00:33:30:05] Matt Deaton: Well, if you're inspired at all, the the possibility of the Ethics Bowl might be able to help elevate democratic discourse, teach moral maturity, humility. For some people, it just doesn't resonate. But if it resonates at all with you, and I suspect many of your audience members will find it resonate, visit EthicsBowl.org.
There you can see how you can get connected with a high school competition. With a college competition, it's also being organized on the middle school level. This is something that's a global there's a Ethics Olympiad. Is is just ethics bowl in Australia, China and India.
Ethics Cup in the UK is the same thing. It just has a different name. But what you'll find in the book is a lot about the history of Ethics Bowl. Why it's so beneficial while the cases are so cool, one of the cool things about the cases is that they're released on the high school and the college levels every fall and every spring, and they're always contemporary moral issues and political issues, some of the most difficult issues possible, but they're condensed, usually down into 1 to 2 pages and on the high school level to have some discussion questions.
And so these are the sorts of things that you don't have to be an official ethics Bowl coach to talk about. Any educator could take a look at the case set and then introduce one of those to most any classroom. There's stuff in there that could relate back to biology, to science, possibly even math, maybe some relation to artificial intelligence there, but definitely social studies, government classes, anything that touches on most anything apart from possibly theoretical mathematics. So but in the book you learn about all that stuff, the history, the fact that ethics polls are practiced in prisons.
Friend of mine Count Kyle Robertson took his inter-collegiate ethics team from UC Santa Cruz into San Quentin and held a friendly competition with some students and students there. And some people from Utah happened to be in attendance, and they took at the exposure of prisons back to Utah. A guy in Washington state heard about it and took it to Washington. People in Maryland heard about it and took it to Maryland.
The Maryland incarcerated students got so good at it, they wrote a case that was included in the Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl case set a couple of years ago. So it's not an obscure movement like it used to be. It's grown so much since I first started getting involved since Bob Ladenson founded it back in the mid 90s. And if you're a fan of Braver Angels, if you're a fan of Derate the Hate, I think this is the sort of thing that you would love.
You don't need to read my book to learn about it. You can just go to the website or just Google Ethics Bowl, but the book will give you a lot of the background. [00:35:57:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. And I think this is going to resonate with the with the audience.
I think that there's there's a lot of good here, Matt, that, that people can find so that the website again is Ethics bowl.org and the book is ethics Bowl to the rescue saving democracy by transforming debate. There's been a fantastic conversation. Again, all these things, all these ways to find out more about you. And this book will be in the show notes.
And I do appreciate your time and I appreciate you doing this work, Matt. It's incredibly important. And, and and I'm grateful. [00:36:30:22] Matt Deaton: My pleasure.
Thank you for all you're doing. We're on the same team for sure. Thank you. [00:36:34:13] Wilk Wilkinson: Friends, I want to thank you so much for tuning in.
And if there's anything in this episode that provided exceptional value to you, please make sure to hit that share button. If you haven't done so already, please be sure to subscribe to get the Derate the Hate podcast sent to your email inbox every week. We really are better together. So please take a moment to visit Braver angels.org and consider joining the movement towards civic renewal and bridging our political divide.
This is Wilk wrapping up for the week saying get out there. Be kind to one another. Be grateful for everything you've got. And remember it's up to you to make every day the day that you want it to be.
With that, my friend, I'm going to back on out of here and we will catch you next week. Take care.
Comments & Upvotes