Ethics Bowl: The Debate Where Changing Your Mind Is a Strength – DTH Episode 342 with Matt Deaton

Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply) (https://www.buzzsprout.com/969574/fan_mail/new) Most of us learned that debate means picking a side and defending it no matter what. Dr. Matt Deaton has spent the last fifteen years building something different. In Ethics Bowl, teams get a set of real moral dilemmas months ahead of time, work out what they actually think, and then reason through those cases in front of judges and another team. They don’t have to tear the other side down. If the other team makes a great point, they’re expected to say so. Matt traces the path from a philosophy class that changed his life, to a two-team competition in Knoxville in 2010, to a movement that now runs from middle schools to college campuses to prisons in several states, and abroad as the Ethics Olympiad and Ethics Cup. He and Wilk dig into why performative aggression has taken over our politics, why so many leaders treat changing their minds as weakness, and why Matt calls it the opposite: a sign of moral maturity. The conversation touches on Braver Angels, where Wilk works, and Mónica Guzmán’s book I Never Thought of It That Way. Mónica is a friend of Wilk’s and a Braver Angels colleague, and her idea that we should pay attention to how people arrive at their views is something Matt plans to carry into his own classroom. Key Themes •      Assigned sides vs. honest positions. In traditional debate, you’re told to argue for or against and to win by any means. Matt describes judging a high school round in D.C. where intimidation and false confidence carried the day, and why that looks a lot like our politics. •      Changing your mind is maturity, not weakness. Matt pushes back on the idea that admitting a good point or finding a compromise signals surrender. Wilk shares how he stopped trying to change people’s minds and started trying to open them. •      Coming to learn vs. coming to win. Teaching an ethics class the day after Charlie Kirk’s assassination, Matt gave his students room to talk about it. He credited Kirk’s willingness to engage hard issues face to face, while drawing a distinction between a “prove me wrong” posture and the Socratic stance that the one thing we know is that we don’t know everything. •      Every real issue has thoughtful people on both sides. Ethics Bowl case writers present the strongest version of each position. Students come away more humble, not because every view is equally right, but because the people who disagree with them aren’t morons or monsters. •      The caricatures we build. Between partisan media and social media algorithms, it’s easy to turn people we never actually meet into villains. Wilk connects this to his FOG model of fear, outrage, and grievance. Takeaways •      Listen to understand, not to respond. Treat it as a skill you practice, especially when you’ve been burned by someone on the other side. •      Concede a point when it’s earned. Leading by example won’t convert everyone, but it gives the people who want peace permission to do the same. •      Ask how someone arrived at their view, and ask the same of yourself. Our experiences shape which arguments feel convincing. Learn more and connect with Matt Deaton in the full show notes at www.DerateTheHate.com.  📰 Allsides.com We’re all worn out by the F.O.G. that comes with the daily news, but still want to stay informed. AllSides, a company on a mission to break people out of their filter bubbles, offers a daily newsletter called Balanced News Today. It shows top news stories from across the political spectrum so you can get the full picture and feel better about staying informed. Sign up at: allsides.com/dth-news (http://allsides.com/dth-news)   The world is a better place if we are better people. Be grateful for all you’ve got. Make every day the day that you want it to be! Please follow the DTH podcast on: Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/DerateTheHate) , Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/derate_the_hate/) , Twitter(X) (https://twitter.com/deratethehate) ,  YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/@DerateTheHate) ,  Substack  (https://wilkwilkinson.substack.com/) Subscribe to us wherever you enjoy your audio or from our site. Please leave us a rating and feedback on Apple podcasts or other platforms. You can share your thoughts or request Wilk for a speaking engagement on our contact page: DerateTheHate.com/Contact (https://deratethehate.com/contact) The Derate The Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels — America’s largest grassroots, cross-partisan organization working toward civic renewal and bridging partisan divides. Learn more: BraverAngels.org (https://braverangels.org) Welcome to the Derate The Hate Podcast! *The views expressed by Wilk, his guest hosts &/or guests on the Derate The Hate podcast are their own and should not be attributed to any organization they may otherwise be affiliated with.

Comments & Upvotes