Why I Won't Tell My Students Who I'm Voting For – DTH Episode 339 with April Chatham-Carpenter
Show Notes
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply)
This episode opens a new Derate the Hate series built around the Braver Angels Civic Scholars Council, a cross-partisan group of scholars and practitioners writing about what courageous citizenship looks like in practice. The series came out of a suggestion from Harry Boyte, and it sits close to home for Wilk, who works at Braver Angels and helped shape the organization's courageous citizenship direction.
First up is April Chatham-Carpenter, who teaches communication in Arkansas and serves as the Braver Angels state coordinator there. Her paper, Role Multiplicity in Practice: Practicing Courageous Citizenship in Contested Civic Spaces, starts from a plain observation: none of us show up as just one thing. April is a professor, a department chair, a moderator, a Christian, a mother, and a conservative—often all in the same week, sometimes in the same room. Each role carries different expectations and different risks, and she argues that the choices we make about what to say and what to hold back are where civic courage actually happens.
The conversation stays personal and practical: classrooms, a public television set, a church pew, and the feedback both April and Wilk get from people convinced they're on the wrong team. Wilk has been a guest on April's show, A Braver Arkansas, and brings his own experience as a conservative who regularly gets accused of not being one.
Key Themes
• Holding back isn't the same as staying neutral. When students ask who she's voting for, April doesn't answer—because once they know, that single label tends to swallow everything else they know about her. Drawing on Mónica Guzmán's work on curiosity, she wants her students to see people as more than one piece of their identity, and she models it by refusing to be reduced herself.
• A developer of people, not a shaper of clay. April describes her job as building capacity, not changing minds. She tells her students up front she isn't trying to change their opinions. And when she gets it wrong, she tells them that too—including the day they diagnosed her "lizard brain" after a conflict she didn't handle well, and they talked through what it would take to repair the relationship.
• Persuasion as an invitation. Using invitational rhetoric and Julia Minson's research on conversational receptiveness, April reframes persuasion from winning to bringing people into a conversation where you might learn something too. Her students practice it through structured one-on-one conversations, including Braver Angels' Depolarization Dojo.
• The cost of showing up in a one-party state. Two deans have advised April to keep her Braver Angels work separate from the university. One told her she'd never be conservative enough for the people who would judge her. Wilk knows the feeling: every week he's accused of being either a liberal in disguise or a conservative pandering to the left.
• Knowing who you are. How a person describes themselves matters more than how others describe them. Wilk ties it back to a core Braver Angels practice: speak freely, fully, and without fear—and treat each other with respect while you do it.
Takeaways
• Everyone carries more than one role. Noticing which one you're in, and what it asks of you, is the first step to engaging well.
• Holding back your view can be a form of engagement, not avoidance. Sometimes it's what makes a real conversation possible.
• Owning your mistakes in front of others builds more trust than pretending you don't make them.
• You can't control the labels people put on you. You can stay clear on what you believe and bring your whole self to the conversation.
About Dr. April Chatham-Carpenter
April Chatham-Carpenter is Professor and Chair of the Department of Applied Communication at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock, where she teaches a course on listening and civil dialogue. She serves as Arkansas State Coordinator for Braver Angels and is a member of the Braver Angels Civic Scholars Council. With Glen White, she co-hosts the public television series A Braver Arkansas and the On the Other Hand podcast, sponsored by Braver Angels Arkansas.
Learn more about and connect with April Chatham-Carpenter:
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/april-chatham-carpenter/
TV Show: https://www.pbs.org/show/a-braver-arkansas/
Podcast: https://ontheotherhand.podbean.com/
Resources Mentioned
April's Paper: https://www.beyondintractability.org/cic_documents/courageous-citizenship/Chatham-Carpenter.html
Civic Scholars Council: https://braverangels.org/civic-scholars-council/
Full Paper Collection: https://www.beyondintractability.org/BA-CSC-papers
Braver Angels: https://braverangels.org/
📰 Allsides.com
We’re all worn out by the F.O.G. that comes with the daily news, but still want to stay informed. AllSides, a company on a mission to break people out of their filter bubbles, offers a daily newsletter called Balanced News Today. It shows top news stories from across the political spectrum so you can get the full picture and feel better about staying informed. Sign up at: allsides.com/dth-news
The world is a better place if we are better people. Be grateful for all you’ve got. Make every day the day that you want it to be!
Please follow the DTH podcast on:
Facebook, Instagram, Twitter(X) , YouTube, Substack
Subscribe to us wherever you enjoy your audio or from our site. Please leave us a rating and feedback on Apple podcasts or other platforms. You can share your thoughts or request Wilk for a speaking engagement on our contact page: DerateTheHate.com/Contact
The Derate The Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels — America’s largest grassroots, cross-partisan organization working toward civic renewal and bridging partisan divides. Learn more: BraverAngels.org
Welcome to the Derate The Hate Podcast!
*The views expressed by Wilk, his guest hosts &/or guests on the Derate The Hate podcast are their own and should not be attributed to any organization they may otherwise be affiliated with.
Show Transcript
Transcript is AI generated and may contain errors
[00:00:00:00] Wilk Wilkinson: Every election season. April Chatham Carpenter students ask her the same question who are you voting for? And every time she doesn't tell them, not because she doesn't have an answer. Because she knows that once they hear it, that's all they'll see. Today, we're talking about why holding back isn't the same as staying neutral, and why sometimes that takes more courage than speaking up. Stick with me Welcome back, my friends, to the Derate the hate podcast. I'm your host, Wilk Wilkinson. Your blue collar sage calming outrage and helping to navigate a world divided by fog. And those who would spread that fear, outrage and grievance. The Derate The Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels, America's largest grassroots cross Partisan organization working to make courageous citizenship the honored norm. This podcast amplifies the mission that we share to foster a more respectful and united America, where we build together across political and societal divides each week, through the power of story, conversation, and connection with incredible guests, we work to build bridges instead of barriers, not to change minds on the issues, but to change how we see one another when we differ. Friends, it really is about bettering the world, one attitude at a time. We did not create the hate, but together we can Derate the Hate. So be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Share it with a friend and visit Braver angels.org to join the movement to make courageous citizenship the honored norm. Looking for more news and less bias? Visit our great supporting partner All sides.com for balanced news fueled by media bias ratings. Friends. I am so incredibly grateful that you have joined me for another powerful, Derate the Hate episode. Let's get to it. this episode. Start something new here on Direct Date, a series of conversations with members of the Braver Angels Civic Scholars Council. His Braver Angels has moved into its next chapter on courageous citizenship. The Council took on a question that sounds simple, but at the same time isn't what does it actually look like to be a good citizen right now? Their answers came in the form of papers, and we're going to dig into them one conversation at a time. My first guest is April Chatham Carpenter. April teaches communication at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock, where she runs a class on listening and civil dialog. She's also the Braver Angels state coordinator in Arkansas, and she co-hosts a public television show, A Braver Arkansas, along with the On the Other Hand podcast. I've been a guest on April show, and today she's on mine. Her paper is about something most of us deal with every day without putting the name to it. None of us show up is just one thing. Professor, department chair. Moderator. Christian. Mother. Conservative. Every one of those roles comes with its own expectations and its own risks. April talks about how she decides what to share and what to hold back, why she thinks of herself as a developer of people, and what it's like to be told that she'll never be conservative enough for her own red state. Let's get into it with my friend April Chatham Carpenter. Here we go. April Chatham Carpenter. Welcome to the Derate The Hate podcast. It is very good to see you again today.
[00:03:50:21] April Chatham-Carpenter: Wilk, I’m honored to be here.
[00:03:53:06] Wilk Wilkinson: I am always honored when we get to talk. April, this is a this is a real treat. This is going to be the first in a series of episodes that I am going to do here on the Derate the Hate podcast with members of our Civic Scholars Council at Brave Angels. And you happen to be the first person in that lineup that's going to kick off that series. and I'm glad to, glad to have you here. First we'll talk about, a little bit about you, April, because you have not been on the podcast before. People in the world of Braver Angels know you to some extent, but but a lot of the listeners may not know who you are. So, 1st April, how did you find yourself in the bridge building space and eventually at at Braver Angels.
[00:04:45:00] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, that's a great question. I have for years been a interpersonal communication person, a scholar teacher, and but never had applied those skills to political relationships or political communication at all. And I was spending a year doing an interim director gig in the School of Public Affairs at my current university, and it hosts in one of the units in that that school is political science. And the state coordinator for Braver Angels made a cold call to me and said, do you know anything about this organization called Better Angels? And I at the time? That's the name of it. I said, I have no idea. He started explaining it to me and I'm like, wow, this sounds like a lot of stuff that I do already teaching people to speak and listen well to each other. Let me check it out. So I kind of hung around. Covid happened right after I started checking out and checking it out. I got trained as a moderator in Braver Angels and realized that I could actually bring this into my current academic world. Developed a class on listening and civil dialog, which I'm currently teaching this semester and we offer every fall semester. And I have been very active also in in just kind of helping in the state and nationally in terms of some leadership roles, volunteer as part of my service responsibilities as a faculty member as well with Braver Angels.
[00:06:16:23] Wilk Wilkinson: That's fantastic. Yeah. Going back to the name Better Angels, that's, that that goes back a ways. I came on shortly, shortly after the pandemic began. Well, it was early 2021, and they had already transitioned over to, Braver Angels. But but yeah, the the line better angels are the, the name tag, whatever you want to call it. Better angels obviously originates the, Abraham Lincoln quote, you know, appeal to the better angels of our nature and and one of the and this is why I, I love the work that we do and, the organization is, is bringing together people of, of all different mindsets and, people from different parts of the world. I mean, you've got me who, came to this as blue collar, conservative from the Midwest that was running, running trucking operations. And and then you've got you down in Arkansas who, who very much an academic and a scholar and, and here we are on this podcast together. Going way back to, to the age of or the days of Better Angels. What, what first stood out to you? April. About when when we. When recently. obviously, we've gone through a leadership change here at at Braver Angels last year, Maury Giles took over as the CEO of the organization. And we've been making a lot of changes. And the Civic Scholars Council. Was was one of those changes bringing, bringing this this, you know, large table of civic scholars together to in a meeting of the minds to to write some of these incredible papers, talk a little bit about, you know, how that was, was brought to you and, and explain to you and what since this is going to be the first one in this series. I, I'd love to, you know, get your input on what was that? What was that presented and what was that going to look like, or what does that look like?
[00:08:24:12] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. So it's actually interesting our our former CEO before Maury was David Blankenhorn and David had a real desire to bring together scholars, to kind of be resources for the organization. And I was actually a part of that group, but we never really had any traction in terms of what we did. And so other than just kind of a name on a website, and I was honored to be a part of that and, you know, got to see people from all different kinds of disciplines and academic fields, but also practitioners that were doing work. And so it made me interested and really made me realize at the time that so much of what I kind of think of my academic hat and my volunteer hat sometimes as not connecting, but they actually can connect together. And it gave me a great hope, actually, that I could I could be doing these things in a meaningful way. And so when when Maury took over, he had a real desire to, to frame up that, that braver scholars council in a way that would make it meaningful and have us actually engage in conversation with each other. And he put together, I guess it was, I think it was him that put this together a a steering committee or a steering team. I'm not a part of that. The initial four or 5 or 6 people that are on that, but made up of reds and blues and moderates like we do in Braver Angels, that would actually be people that were practitioners or scholars or what some people like to call practical academics. Right? I love that term. Yeah. And so they actually started developing a framework that we could use to start talking about things like courageous citizenship, which, you know, I think until Maury, we really hadn't thought about the work in angels as doing that.
[00:10:20:08] Wilk Wilkinson: And the the courageous citizenship next chapter in Braver Angels is, is something that I was part of helping to, to develop. And, and there was a lot of us came to the, the realization that the business we are in is, is a courageous citizenship building across difference. And, and when I found out about the Civic Scholars Council coming together to write these papers on courageous citizenship, and, and when our, our friend Harry Boyte came and and presented me with the idea of this series and and and really, you know, diving deeper into what, what citizenship means to each of us and the importance of citizenship and, and, because a lot of that, I think now gets lost. And I mean, just the, the jargon that you see on, you know, throughout media and stuff like that, we, we get to hung up on words, but we really forget what the actual thing is that we're talking about, And these papers that, that I've, I've had the opportunity to read a few so far from the Civic Scholars Council have been fantastic. And yours, that we're going to dive into here for, for a little bit is, is a is among just, just some incredible works that I've had the, the opportunity to read. So. So then, April, let's talk about I guess it's the role of multiplicity in contested civic spaces. Is that.
[00:11:51:03] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah.
[00:11:52:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Remembering that. Correct.
[00:11:53:03] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, something like that. It's role multiplicity. And you know we as academics we use these terms that like we don't I don't ever use the term multiplicity in my everyday language. But I had. To make this a little academic. Either although they said that this could be read by a variety of people, but I when I was deciding what to write for this paper, I was thinking, you know, if my role as a, as an educator and also even as a moderator in Braver Angels and and now in my work as a Braver Angels state coordinator as well, I see myself as a developer, right? A developer of people as well as myself. And so, I, I was thinking about, you know, kind of what, what goes on in my head. And then that translates into behavior in terms of the choices that I make when I am working to develop people in terms of something like courageous citizenship, which I really believe is a set of communication behaviors and mindsets, I think it's it's both our kind of the way of looking at the world, but it's also our way of of interacting in the world.
[00:12:59:15] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah, absolutely. And and this is one of the things that's, I don't know, sets. perception of braver angels, apart from the actual work of braver angels and and that's that, you know, we get we've been accused at times of being just dialog for dialog sake and things like that, and and communications all great. But we want to do something. But that's that's the thing is, is it's hard to do stuff with people. It's hard to build across difference if you're not taking the time to learn and build that relationship with somebody, and building that relationship with somebody is a step in the process. And communication is a huge part of of that building. I love the idea of being a developer of people. I, I, I love that I, I just the way that it sounds, I, I, I don't know why. I'm just thinking of the, the, the biblical phrase of fisher of men. I don't know why. But for of people is, is is awesome.
[00:14:02:05] April Chatham-Carpenter: And it sounds a little arrogant, I'll have to say, with a will because it sounds like, okay, I'm the one that's shaping the clay, right? And I really do not see myself as that. I see myself and I tell my students I'm like, I am learning alongside of you. But if I can set up opportunities to learn that we both can learn that we both can grow, then we are both developing and and one of the things that I think my students like about me is that I share, and I'm about the times in which I don't do it. Well. I still remember going into class a couple of years ago after I had just, not handled a conflict situation that was not politically related, but not handled it well. And I came in and I told them about it and they're like, oh, you're. And I'd been talking about the, the amygdala and how it can take over our brain when our emotions can like, you know, be so out of control. And I'm like, and they said, your lizard brain took over. And I'm like, yes, my lizard brain took over there like, it happens to you too. And I'm like, yes. And I'm like, what has to happen afterwards? And so we talked about, I'm going to have to repair this relationship. I'm going to have to do things differently. I have to rebuild. And and so it's from that I saw, as I say, that developer, I just want your listeners to know, I'm not thinking that I am the expert. That is like pushing these people into the mold that I think they should be in. I want people to make the choices. I told my students at the beginning of this semester, I am not trying to change your opinion.
[00:15:43:05] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah.
[00:15:43:20] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, I am wanting to build your capacity. Yes. Your capacity to be able to be in situations in which you don't feel comfortable and can lean into that discomfort to build understanding of the other person.
[00:16:02:20] Wilk Wilkinson: I'm so glad you made that distinction, because, yeah. And going back to that phrase again, a developer of people. Yeah. Not molding somebody, not not turning them into or fundamentally transforming them into what you want them to be, but helping them to build the capacity to be the best person that they can be. It's a very, very different thing. And yeah, there's a whole portion of in a book that I'm working on about the amygdala, and that's a story for another time. But, yeah, it's I love that. And I don't know, it's it's kind of funny to think about the students, you know, coming to realization. Oh, man, she's human too. You know, she she's dealt with the same things that we deal with, you know, because they, you know, sometimes people think of their, their teacher or their boss as something other than and then just another human being that has the capacity to feel and, and make mistakes and, and like.
[00:17:08:02] April Chatham-Carpenter: That, you know, as a faculty in higher education, we get a bad rep sometimes, right? I mean, we're we're perceived as people that shove political ideology down the throats of our students. And I'm sure that is true. Some institutions and some faculty, but in the communication field, I certainly hope that we are not known for that, that we're actually teaching people to think on their own and to communicate in ways that will help them build their relationships up.
[00:17:41:03] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. Well, and that brings up a point that you make in the paper about how you, you intentionally hold back your own political ideology. You don't bring that to the forefront in those conversations that you're you're either moderate moderating or guiding or, or when you're talk, talk a little bit more about that April dive into that. The, the importance of that and how. Holding back your own per second. Let's see if I'm remembering this correctly. Holding back your own perspective. It's not the same as remaining neutral. But it taught dive into that, because that was one of the parts of the paper that that that immediately stood out to me as being a hugely important part of this. This paper.
[00:18:32:17] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. I really framed the paper around communicative choices that we make. Right. And I think even non can make making these choices. And so, you know, when I'm in the classroom and especially during a political presidential election year, students will push and they're like who are you going to vote for? Who are you going to vote for? And I'm like, and what I want. My comeback phrase is always, if I tell you who I'm going to vote for, your perception will change with me, because you will immediately see me really, as in one frame, and it's the frame of who I'm going to vote for. Even though you already know me, even you already know the whole semester worth of material, you know? And so but it's difficult and I'm sure students, I, I use this sometimes. I also teach research methods and sometimes I'll, I'll tell students the advantage of quantitative and qualitative research methods and, and then I'll ask them at the end, you know, which do you think I like the best. And they'll be like oh it's that one or oh it's that one. And I'm like, actually most of my research is done with that one. And you picked wrong. Now why did you think that? And so because I try and I'm hoping that my students will actually label me incorrectly or, or say she just said that I thought she was that now I. Wow. She, you know, and and although we don't use this term a lot in, in academics. I mean, in we do it in Braver angels. It's nuanced. Our identities are nuanced. I am a a Christian, grew up conservative. I am a woman. I am a faculty member. I am a mother. I serve at my church in all my I'm a fact at which one of those identities. And if I tell you who I vote for, all of a sudden that becomes the only thing the most that you can see. And so I don't want students to to judge me by one thing. And I really emphasize that for them. I said, if you also want, you know, if you just judge a person by one person, partial portion of their identity, it doesn't matter what it is, which portion of their identity, then you limit the getting to know them as a beautiful human being.
[00:20:55:18] Wilk Wilkinson: That's right, that's right. When we take the just 1 or 2 things that we know about a person and then build a whole caricature around that particular part of their identity, we miss out on so much. And, and you actually reference another great friend of ours, Monica Guzman's book. And in the way that, you know, we have to engage with curiosity and often if we kind of pigeonhole somebody or caricature them based on one particular thing, we lose the rest of who they are.
[00:21:30:02] April Chatham-Carpenter: Absolutely. And that's one of the books that I, I've used for several years now in my listening a civil dialog class, Monica actually came to our campus. She was the diversity speaker that came to our campus, which before now we can't use the word diversity on campus, but it's okay. She still was one of those speakers. Yeah, yeah.
[00:21:47:03] Wilk Wilkinson: Well, we can use it on this podcast. Yeah. Monica Guzman, one of my favorite. Favorite people of all time. She's, her and I have done a lot of work together over the years, and and and seeing her quoted in this paper is, is definitely, definitely nice. I always love when I see her works being quoted so let's talk about a little bit more about then, Okay, so there's four, four practices that you talk about in the, in the paper. When we think about, different roles, contested civic spaces, break down the four, and then we'll talk a little bit about each one. I mean, we've obviously talked a little bit about the first one now, but but talk about the four practices that you highlighted.
[00:22:28:23] April Chatham-Carpenter: So so these are these are communicative choices. Right. That's how I frame it within the paper is so I have to figure out my roles and think about strategically disclosing. So I've already talked about that really. And even that's the act of holding back things right or asking questions and helping them remain curious. The second one is to actually reframe persuasion. I call it through kind of a lens of two lenses. One is invitational rhetoric, which is something in my my field, which is that you're inviting other people into the conversation. I think about the debates that are done in Braver Angels as an example of invitational rhetoric. Yeah, you've got multiple perspectives. You're asking curious or clarifying questions, and by the end, you know, you you see something as much bigger than you ever anticipated when you first went in in terms of your perspective, because you've invited them into conversation with you. Julia Minson talks about the term conversational receptiveness. She was actually at the last convention, the angels convention in Philadelphia. And conversational receptiveness is basically my ability to say, I am going to be open to listening and to possibly having my mind changed. Not because I don't have an opinion, but realizing I may not know everything yet. So that's a second choice that we have, is to kind of reframe persuasion from winning to actually inviting people into a conversation that's built around curiosity. Yeah. The third one is that as an as an educator, I have to develop intentional learning environment. So I think the example that I gave there is that I have students actually engage in 1 to 1 conversations with structured guides that they're going to be using this semester. They're going to be using the Depolarization dojo as one of the opportunities for that the Braver Angels has. But I'm using a technique this semester also called sway and which it's a it's a it's a they actually are paired on topics based on if they agree or not. And they have a 30 minute chat based conversation just as a beginning to try to see how they can ask curious questions. And so I try to build build opportunities for them to actually get to know each other. And then the and no other people's opinion. And the fourth one is the one that I struggle with probably the most, which is how do I navigate the political context in which my institution finds itself. Yeah, I'm in a pretty much one party state. I mean, I'm in a blue bubble within a one party state because little Rock, is pretty, is more progressive, but my state government is is one party for the most part. And I still remember when I got ready to do the podcast, on the other hand, which I do with one of my Braver Angels colleagues as well as the TV show, I asked my dean, I two different deans have told me the same thing basically is, you know, this does not need to be associated with the university because we don't know for sure what it is that you're going to be saying on these podcasts or this TV show, and we could get backlash as a university. So that's one. But secondly, they said, you call yourself conservative, but we don't know if you'll ever be as conservative as you need to be for everybody to like you, who considers himself conservative in our state. And I'm like, okay, so now I've, I have to protect myself with my students, letting them not know who I am. Okay. That's that I can do. I'll bring in examples from both sides. They're going to be watching a video from the Enemies Project, which is, you know, of their choice and they're going to see multiple sides presented, you know, which is another kind of bridge building space that people, people are, you know, in. But so I can I can figure out how to do this in the classroom. But every single thing that I say on a podcast, on our new TV show that we have that's on the PBS affiliated station, I don't know how that's going to impact me, and I'm really glad.
[00:26:54:06] Wilk Wilkinson: I'm glad.
[00:26:54:19] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, I, I'm really kind of glad I'm close to retirement. And my students can also record my videos in class or I, because I have some students that are online and I have a face to face class. And so I don't know where those videos are going to land. Sure, you another unlisted YouTube videos right now, but, what if somebody sends one to somebody that thinks, oh, she based on what she just said in class today or that clip, she needs to be fired as a professor. That's hard.
[00:27:26:03] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. No, it's very difficult. And, you know, I'm very grateful now because I was in the corporate world for a long time. while I was doing this, but before I came on board full time at Brave Angels and. And. Yeah, you're always wondering, you know, is it is has something I said. Going to land because I've obviously been in my more than my share of a very controversial conversations. I was a guest on the enemies project, so I don't know if what episode that your, your students are going to be watching, but I was on the enemies project with Larry Rosen, and a state rep from the state of Minnesota here. But yeah, going back and I'll have you dig a dig a bit deeper into this April, because that idea of not being read enough in a red state it's I think that's interesting because I, I'm about as conservative, like a real conservative, not like a lot of the conservative people that claim to be conservative today. I'm about as conservative as you can get. But it's very strange because every week I'll end up getting some feedback where I'm either, you know, somebody accuses me as being a liberal that goes by conservative or I'll get I'll, I'll be accused of being a, you know, a super conservative that's just placating to liberals. I get that, all that stuff. And I'm sure you do to talk a little bit more about that and how when, when you're negotiating that, that institutional and, and political tension, what does that look like for you?
[00:29:08:11] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. So, It it comes in many different ways. You know, one thing is, is that I just end up not having my department associated or my university affiliation associated with my Brave Angels task. And yet I applied for a service award that involved so much of my Angel stuff. And I got the service award from the university. And so it's not like they don't recognize things and they don't appreciate it. But, there's a lot of fear these days. Wilke and I, I even I'm a department chair in my, my current department, and I would say most of my faculty, if not all of them are, would consider themselves to be progressive. And, and so when I come out also and they maybe watch one of my, my episodes or listen and they hear me say I'm conservative. I also am worried about, well, are they going to think, how am I? How am I going to be as a as a boss for them? Right. Yeah. And then I know my students could put, you know, potentially watch those and then find out where I stand to. Doesn't say who I'm going to vote for necessarily because I always vote for the candidate, not for the party. And so, which some people may, may say, well, that doesn't make you truly conservative. So you do get questioned, right? Yeah. No. And so, I, I do think that how we label ourselves to me, it's more important how a person chooses to describe themselves than it is how how another person describes them.
[00:30:50:07] Wilk Wilkinson: Sure, that's great, but that.
[00:30:52:13] April Chatham-Carpenter: Doesn't mean that you don't get criticized as you were talking about that. You do. And that was what my my initial dean that now she's at another university said to me, she's like, April, you think this, but you're never going to be what they want you to be. That's right. And so if I can be truly my whole person, I bring my whole person into this. But I have to make choices every time I'm even on the television show that that Glenn and I are doing. And I know you're a guest on that as well, have been. And so it is. There are times in which I'm like, okay, I got I got to play the conservative role here. And so I'm going to push back on Glenn some. And even then how I push back, I want to represent good communication skills or the braver way we would call it in braver angels. And yet there are times even then that I'm teasing or I'm kind of pushing back or playing with him, and he will say during a break, April, that was too much. And I'm like, I'm just trying to make this interesting for the audience. Yeah. So, you know, playing to your audience, whoever that audience is, is something that we learn to do in media, right, that we learn to do in, in entertainment, that we learn to do, I suppose in education as well. You want your, your students to learn and like you and so but you also want to be true to yourself. Yeah. So at some point, I mean, sometimes I'm, you know, even sitting in church and I'm just like, okay, so what they just said from the pulpit, do I need to do I need to confront because I don't really agree with that? Or do I just sit and just like, okay, well, it doesn't affect me personally, so I'll just not choose to say anything because I want to maintain my respectability. So it's hard.
[00:33:03:17] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. I don't know if I really.
[00:33:04:23] April Chatham-Carpenter: Answered your question though.
[00:33:06:04] Wilk Wilkinson: Well, I don't know, but everything you said landed well, I mean, it's a it's a it's a very important what you're saying. And it I think the biggest thing that I'm taking away from that particular part of this conversation, April, is, is that it's not always about how others perceive you, but how you perceive yourself and then being true to yourself. You know, at Braver Angels, part of the Braver angels way that we really promote is getting up there, speaking freely, fully and without fear. And, and then treating each other with respect. We can't control what somebody is going to say about us or what somebody's going to think about us. But you know, like I said, I, I've, I've been I've been accused so many times of, of not being a conservative because modern this modern kind of post liberalism or illiberal populism, whatever you want to call it. Now, that I may not necessarily see as conservatives, but they, they define it as conservatism is not what I consider traditional conservatism. So so there's an impasse there. Right. And but the reality is, is, is I know what I am and I know who I am and I know what I believe. And and as long as I'm true to myself in April, as long as you're true to yourself, we get up there, speak freely, fully, without fear. That's great. A citizenship, right? And, and when we're having these conversations, going back to the idea of your paper. Right. Role multiplicity in practice, we have to play different roles. Sometimes we have to. We have to keep ourselves in check and and listen when when it might be more convenient for us just to just to jump in and and and talk our way and and, again, going back to the idea that you talked about earlier is, you know, the, you know, just because we we hold back what we are about doesn't mean we're neutral or doesn't mean we don't care about what's being talked about. But sometimes it just takes that to the to be part of a, an effective back and forth and an effective, conversation. April. We've we've definitely gone. Right to the end of our time here. Probably a little bit over. I'm sure you and I could go on for for a very long time. But how do people find these papers? where can people find the the papers from our our civic scholars council. I know, I know there's there's ways to get them on Substack. We're going to obviously link to them in the show notes here on the Derate The Hate website.
[00:35:46:21] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. So if people will actually go to the Braver Angels website. There is a under the what we do there is a Civic Scholars Council link there and it actually has the library there. It's says CSC library papers on courageous citizenship, and it defines what the Civic Scholars Council is as well, and tells who the co-chairs are. And and so yeah, people can find a lot of information there, but that's their that's actually on the page now they're, they're publishing them in this I guess it's like a Substack as well too, but it can count as a publication for us as, as scholars then, and a publication called A Beyond Intractability. The word intractability means really difficult conflicts. So if we're going beyond intractability, we're actually working on constructively handling these difficult conflicts. And so that's what it links out to. My paper was one of the first groups that was actually, published there. And I think the rest of them are coming soon if they're not already there.
[00:36:55:13] Wilk Wilkinson: Very good. We'll make sure those links are in the show notes. People can find them there, and then they can always go to BraverAngels.org but yeah, beyond intractability, it's a there's a Substack and a newsletter, and it's just great to great that they're helping us get these, get these papers published. April Chatham carpenter. It's been a real pleasure. I've very much enjoyed it, and we'll look forward to the next conversation.
[00:37:21:12] April Chatham-Carpenter: Thanks for all you're doing for having me on today.
[00:37:24:12] Wilk Wilkinson: Friends, I want to thank you so much for tuning in. And if there's anything in this episode that provided exceptional value to you, please make sure to hit that share button. If you haven't done so already, please be sure to subscribe to get the Derate The Hate podcast sent to your email inbox every week. We really are better together. So please take a moment to visit Braver angels.org and consider joining the movement towards civic renewal and bridging our political divides. This is Wilk wrapping up for the week saying get out there. Be kind to one another. Be grateful for everything you've got. And remember, it's up to you to make every day the day that you want it to be. With that, my friend, I'm going to back on out of here and we will catch you next week. Take care.
Also Listen
-
Ethics Bowl: The Debate Where Changing Your Mind Is a Strength – DTH Episode 342 with Matt Deaton
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply) Most -
Leaving Groupthink: A Former Progressive Operative on Learning to Think for Herself – DTH Episode 341 with Sabrina Joy Stevens
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply) Sabri -
Nothing Is Waste: Turning Tension Into Common Ground – DTH Episode 340 with Derek Richard Thomas and Alizabeth Thomas
Send Wilk a text with your feedback! (incoming msgs only - I can't reply) Derek
Transcript
Transcript is AI generated and may contain errors [00:00:00:00] Wilk Wilkinson: Every election season. April Chatham Carpenter students ask her the same question who are you voting for? And every time she doesn't tell them, not because she doesn't have an answer. Because she knows that once they hear it, that's all they'll see.
Today, we're talking about why holding back isn't the same as staying neutral, and why sometimes that takes more courage than speaking up. Stick with me Welcome back, my friends, to the Derate the hate podcast. I'm your host, Wilk Wilkinson. Your blue collar sage calming outrage and helping to navigate a world divided by fog.
And those who would spread that fear, outrage and grievance. The Derate The Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels, America's largest grassroots cross Partisan organization working to make courageous citizenship the honored norm. This podcast amplifies the mission that we share to foster a more respectful and united America, where we build together across political and societal divides each week, through the power of story, conversation, and connection with incredible guests, we work to build bridges instead of barriers, not to change minds on the issues, but to change how we see one another when we differ. Friends, it really is about bettering the world, one attitude at a time.
We did not create the hate, but together we can Derate the Hate. So be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Share it with a friend and visit Braver angels.org to join the movement to make courageous citizenship the honored norm. Looking for more news and less bias?
Visit our great supporting partner All sides.com for balanced news fueled by media bias ratings. Friends. I am so incredibly grateful that you have joined me for another powerful, Derate the Hate episode. Let's get to it.
this episode. Start something new here on Direct Date, a series of conversations with members of the Braver Angels Civic Scholars Council. His Braver Angels has moved into its next chapter on courageous citizenship. The Council took on a question that sounds simple, but at the same time isn't what does it actually look like to be a good citizen right now?
Their answers came in the form of papers, and we're going to dig into them one conversation at a time. My first guest is April Chatham Carpenter. April teaches communication at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock, where she runs a class on listening and civil dialog. She's also the Braver Angels state coordinator in Arkansas, and she co-hosts a public television show, A Braver Arkansas, along with the On the Other Hand podcast.
I've been a guest on April show, and today she's on mine. Her paper is about something most of us deal with every day without putting the name to it. None of us show up is just one thing. Professor, department chair.
Moderator. Christian. Mother. Conservative.
Every one of those roles comes with its own expectations and its own risks. April talks about how she decides what to share and what to hold back, why she thinks of herself as a developer of people, and what it's like to be told that she'll never be conservative enough for her own red state. Let's get into it with my friend April Chatham Carpenter. Here we go.
April Chatham Carpenter. Welcome to the Derate The Hate podcast. It is very good to see you again today. [00:03:50:21] April Chatham-Carpenter: Wilk, I’m honored to be here.
[00:03:53:06] Wilk Wilkinson: I am always honored when we get to talk. April, this is a this is a real treat. This is going to be the first in a series of episodes that I am going to do here on the Derate the Hate podcast with members of our Civic Scholars Council at Brave Angels. And you happen to be the first person in that lineup that's going to kick off that series.
and I'm glad to, glad to have you here. First we'll talk about, a little bit about you, April, because you have not been on the podcast before. People in the world of Braver Angels know you to some extent, but but a lot of the listeners may not know who you are. So, 1st April, how did you find yourself in the bridge building space and eventually at at Braver Angels.
[00:04:45:00] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, that's a great question. I have for years been a interpersonal communication person, a scholar teacher, and but never had applied those skills to political relationships or political communication at all. And I was spending a year doing an interim director gig in the School of Public Affairs at my current university, and it hosts in one of the units in that that school is political science. And the state coordinator for Braver Angels made a cold call to me and said, do you know anything about this organization called Better Angels?
And I at the time? That's the name of it. I said, I have no idea. He started explaining it to me and I'm like, wow, this sounds like a lot of stuff that I do already teaching people to speak and listen well to each other.
Let me check it out. So I kind of hung around. Covid happened right after I started checking out and checking it out. I got trained as a moderator in Braver Angels and realized that I could actually bring this into my current academic world.
Developed a class on listening and civil dialog, which I'm currently teaching this semester and we offer every fall semester. And I have been very active also in in just kind of helping in the state and nationally in terms of some leadership roles, volunteer as part of my service responsibilities as a faculty member as well with Braver Angels. [00:06:16:23] Wilk Wilkinson: That's fantastic. Yeah.
Going back to the name Better Angels, that's, that that goes back a ways. I came on shortly, shortly after the pandemic began. Well, it was early 2021, and they had already transitioned over to, Braver Angels. But but yeah, the the line better angels are the, the name tag, whatever you want to call it.
Better angels obviously originates the, Abraham Lincoln quote, you know, appeal to the better angels of our nature and and one of the and this is why I, I love the work that we do and, the organization is, is bringing together people of, of all different mindsets and, people from different parts of the world. I mean, you've got me who, came to this as blue collar, conservative from the Midwest that was running, running trucking operations. And and then you've got you down in Arkansas who, who very much an academic and a scholar and, and here we are on this podcast together. Going way back to, to the age of or the days of Better Angels.
What, what first stood out to you? April. About when when we. When recently.
obviously, we've gone through a leadership change here at at Braver Angels last year, Maury Giles took over as the CEO of the organization. And we've been making a lot of changes. And the Civic Scholars Council. Was was one of those changes bringing, bringing this this, you know, large table of civic scholars together to in a meeting of the minds to to write some of these incredible papers, talk a little bit about, you know, how that was, was brought to you and, and explain to you and what since this is going to be the first one in this series.
I, I'd love to, you know, get your input on what was that? What was that presented and what was that going to look like, or what does that look like? [00:08:24:12] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. So it's actually interesting our our former CEO before Maury was David Blankenhorn and David had a real desire to bring together scholars, to kind of be resources for the organization.
And I was actually a part of that group, but we never really had any traction in terms of what we did. And so other than just kind of a name on a website, and I was honored to be a part of that and, you know, got to see people from all different kinds of disciplines and academic fields, but also practitioners that were doing work. And so it made me interested and really made me realize at the time that so much of what I kind of think of my academic hat and my volunteer hat sometimes as not connecting, but they actually can connect together. And it gave me a great hope, actually, that I could I could be doing these things in a meaningful way.
And so when when Maury took over, he had a real desire to, to frame up that, that braver scholars council in a way that would make it meaningful and have us actually engage in conversation with each other. And he put together, I guess it was, I think it was him that put this together a a steering committee or a steering team. I'm not a part of that. The initial four or 5 or 6 people that are on that, but made up of reds and blues and moderates like we do in Braver Angels, that would actually be people that were practitioners or scholars or what some people like to call practical academics.
Right? I love that term. Yeah. And so they actually started developing a framework that we could use to start talking about things like courageous citizenship, which, you know, I think until Maury, we really hadn't thought about the work in angels as doing that.
[00:10:20:08] Wilk Wilkinson: And the the courageous citizenship next chapter in Braver Angels is, is something that I was part of helping to, to develop. And, and there was a lot of us came to the, the realization that the business we are in is, is a courageous citizenship building across difference. And, and when I found out about the Civic Scholars Council coming together to write these papers on courageous citizenship, and, and when our, our friend Harry Boyte came and and presented me with the idea of this series and and and really, you know, diving deeper into what, what citizenship means to each of us and the importance of citizenship and, and, because a lot of that, I think now gets lost. And I mean, just the, the jargon that you see on, you know, throughout media and stuff like that, we, we get to hung up on words, but we really forget what the actual thing is that we're talking about, And these papers that, that I've, I've had the opportunity to read a few so far from the Civic Scholars Council have been fantastic.
And yours, that we're going to dive into here for, for a little bit is, is a is among just, just some incredible works that I've had the, the opportunity to read. So. So then, April, let's talk about I guess it's the role of multiplicity in contested civic spaces. Is that.
[00:11:51:03] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. [00:11:52:06] Wilk Wilkinson: Remembering that. Correct. [00:11:53:03] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, something like that.
It's role multiplicity. And you know we as academics we use these terms that like we don't I don't ever use the term multiplicity in my everyday language. But I had. To make this a little academic.
Either although they said that this could be read by a variety of people, but I when I was deciding what to write for this paper, I was thinking, you know, if my role as a, as an educator and also even as a moderator in Braver Angels and and now in my work as a Braver Angels state coordinator as well, I see myself as a developer, right? A developer of people as well as myself. And so, I, I was thinking about, you know, kind of what, what goes on in my head. And then that translates into behavior in terms of the choices that I make when I am working to develop people in terms of something like courageous citizenship, which I really believe is a set of communication behaviors and mindsets, I think it's it's both our kind of the way of looking at the world, but it's also our way of of interacting in the world.
[00:12:59:15] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah, absolutely. And and this is one of the things that's, I don't know, sets. perception of braver angels, apart from the actual work of braver angels and and that's that, you know, we get we've been accused at times of being just dialog for dialog sake and things like that, and and communications all great. But we want to do something.
But that's that's the thing is, is it's hard to do stuff with people. It's hard to build across difference if you're not taking the time to learn and build that relationship with somebody, and building that relationship with somebody is a step in the process. And communication is a huge part of of that building. I love the idea of being a developer of people.
I, I, I love that I, I just the way that it sounds, I, I, I don't know why. I'm just thinking of the, the, the biblical phrase of fisher of men. I don't know why. But for of people is, is is awesome.
[00:14:02:05] April Chatham-Carpenter: And it sounds a little arrogant, I'll have to say, with a will because it sounds like, okay, I'm the one that's shaping the clay, right? And I really do not see myself as that. I see myself and I tell my students I'm like, I am learning alongside of you. But if I can set up opportunities to learn that we both can learn that we both can grow, then we are both developing and and one of the things that I think my students like about me is that I share, and I'm about the times in which I don't do it.
Well. I still remember going into class a couple of years ago after I had just, not handled a conflict situation that was not politically related, but not handled it well. And I came in and I told them about it and they're like, oh, you're. And I'd been talking about the, the amygdala and how it can take over our brain when our emotions can like, you know, be so out of control.
And I'm like, and they said, your lizard brain took over. And I'm like, yes, my lizard brain took over there like, it happens to you too. And I'm like, yes. And I'm like, what has to happen afterwards?
And so we talked about, I'm going to have to repair this relationship. I'm going to have to do things differently. I have to rebuild. And and so it's from that I saw, as I say, that developer, I just want your listeners to know, I'm not thinking that I am the expert.
That is like pushing these people into the mold that I think they should be in. I want people to make the choices. I told my students at the beginning of this semester, I am not trying to change your opinion. [00:15:43:05] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah.
[00:15:43:20] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, I am wanting to build your capacity. Yes. Your capacity to be able to be in situations in which you don't feel comfortable and can lean into that discomfort to build understanding of the other person. [00:16:02:20] Wilk Wilkinson: I'm so glad you made that distinction, because, yeah.
And going back to that phrase again, a developer of people. Yeah. Not molding somebody, not not turning them into or fundamentally transforming them into what you want them to be, but helping them to build the capacity to be the best person that they can be. It's a very, very different thing.
And yeah, there's a whole portion of in a book that I'm working on about the amygdala, and that's a story for another time. But, yeah, it's I love that. And I don't know, it's it's kind of funny to think about the students, you know, coming to realization. Oh, man, she's human too.
You know, she she's dealt with the same things that we deal with, you know, because they, you know, sometimes people think of their, their teacher or their boss as something other than and then just another human being that has the capacity to feel and, and make mistakes and, and like. [00:17:08:02] April Chatham-Carpenter: That, you know, as a faculty in higher education, we get a bad rep sometimes, right? I mean, we're we're perceived as people that shove political ideology down the throats of our students. And I'm sure that is true.
Some institutions and some faculty, but in the communication field, I certainly hope that we are not known for that, that we're actually teaching people to think on their own and to communicate in ways that will help them build their relationships up. [00:17:41:03] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. Well, and that brings up a point that you make in the paper about how you, you intentionally hold back your own political ideology. You don't bring that to the forefront in those conversations that you're you're either moderate moderating or guiding or, or when you're talk, talk a little bit more about that April dive into that.
The, the importance of that and how. Holding back your own per second. Let's see if I'm remembering this correctly. Holding back your own perspective.
It's not the same as remaining neutral. But it taught dive into that, because that was one of the parts of the paper that that that immediately stood out to me as being a hugely important part of this. This paper. [00:18:32:17] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah.
I really framed the paper around communicative choices that we make. Right. And I think even non can make making these choices. And so, you know, when I'm in the classroom and especially during a political presidential election year, students will push and they're like who are you going to vote for?
Who are you going to vote for? And I'm like, and what I want. My comeback phrase is always, if I tell you who I'm going to vote for, your perception will change with me, because you will immediately see me really, as in one frame, and it's the frame of who I'm going to vote for. Even though you already know me, even you already know the whole semester worth of material, you know?
And so but it's difficult and I'm sure students, I, I use this sometimes. I also teach research methods and sometimes I'll, I'll tell students the advantage of quantitative and qualitative research methods and, and then I'll ask them at the end, you know, which do you think I like the best. And they'll be like oh it's that one or oh it's that one. And I'm like, actually most of my research is done with that one.
And you picked wrong. Now why did you think that? And so because I try and I'm hoping that my students will actually label me incorrectly or, or say she just said that I thought she was that now I. Wow.
She, you know, and and although we don't use this term a lot in, in academics. I mean, in we do it in Braver angels. It's nuanced. Our identities are nuanced.
I am a a Christian, grew up conservative. I am a woman. I am a faculty member. I am a mother.
I serve at my church in all my I'm a fact at which one of those identities. And if I tell you who I vote for, all of a sudden that becomes the only thing the most that you can see. And so I don't want students to to judge me by one thing. And I really emphasize that for them.
I said, if you also want, you know, if you just judge a person by one person, partial portion of their identity, it doesn't matter what it is, which portion of their identity, then you limit the getting to know them as a beautiful human being. [00:20:55:18] Wilk Wilkinson: That's right, that's right. When we take the just 1 or 2 things that we know about a person and then build a whole caricature around that particular part of their identity, we miss out on so much. And, and you actually reference another great friend of ours, Monica Guzman's book.
And in the way that, you know, we have to engage with curiosity and often if we kind of pigeonhole somebody or caricature them based on one particular thing, we lose the rest of who they are. [00:21:30:02] April Chatham-Carpenter: Absolutely. And that's one of the books that I, I've used for several years now in my listening a civil dialog class, Monica actually came to our campus. She was the diversity speaker that came to our campus, which before now we can't use the word diversity on campus, but it's okay.
She still was one of those speakers. Yeah, yeah. [00:21:47:03] Wilk Wilkinson: Well, we can use it on this podcast. Yeah.
Monica Guzman, one of my favorite. Favorite people of all time. She's, her and I have done a lot of work together over the years, and and and seeing her quoted in this paper is, is definitely, definitely nice. I always love when I see her works being quoted so let's talk about a little bit more about then, Okay, so there's four, four practices that you talk about in the, in the paper.
When we think about, different roles, contested civic spaces, break down the four, and then we'll talk a little bit about each one. I mean, we've obviously talked a little bit about the first one now, but but talk about the four practices that you highlighted. [00:22:28:23] April Chatham-Carpenter: So so these are these are communicative choices. Right.
That's how I frame it within the paper is so I have to figure out my roles and think about strategically disclosing. So I've already talked about that really. And even that's the act of holding back things right or asking questions and helping them remain curious. The second one is to actually reframe persuasion.
I call it through kind of a lens of two lenses. One is invitational rhetoric, which is something in my my field, which is that you're inviting other people into the conversation. I think about the debates that are done in Braver Angels as an example of invitational rhetoric. Yeah, you've got multiple perspectives.
You're asking curious or clarifying questions, and by the end, you know, you you see something as much bigger than you ever anticipated when you first went in in terms of your perspective, because you've invited them into conversation with you. Julia Minson talks about the term conversational receptiveness. She was actually at the last convention, the angels convention in Philadelphia. And conversational receptiveness is basically my ability to say, I am going to be open to listening and to possibly having my mind changed.
Not because I don't have an opinion, but realizing I may not know everything yet. So that's a second choice that we have, is to kind of reframe persuasion from winning to actually inviting people into a conversation that's built around curiosity. Yeah. The third one is that as an as an educator, I have to develop intentional learning environment.
So I think the example that I gave there is that I have students actually engage in 1 to 1 conversations with structured guides that they're going to be using this semester. They're going to be using the Depolarization dojo as one of the opportunities for that the Braver Angels has. But I'm using a technique this semester also called sway and which it's a it's a it's a they actually are paired on topics based on if they agree or not. And they have a 30 minute chat based conversation just as a beginning to try to see how they can ask curious questions.
And so I try to build build opportunities for them to actually get to know each other. And then the and no other people's opinion. And the fourth one is the one that I struggle with probably the most, which is how do I navigate the political context in which my institution finds itself. Yeah, I'm in a pretty much one party state.
I mean, I'm in a blue bubble within a one party state because little Rock, is pretty, is more progressive, but my state government is is one party for the most part. And I still remember when I got ready to do the podcast, on the other hand, which I do with one of my Braver Angels colleagues as well as the TV show, I asked my dean, I two different deans have told me the same thing basically is, you know, this does not need to be associated with the university because we don't know for sure what it is that you're going to be saying on these podcasts or this TV show, and we could get backlash as a university. So that's one. But secondly, they said, you call yourself conservative, but we don't know if you'll ever be as conservative as you need to be for everybody to like you, who considers himself conservative in our state.
And I'm like, okay, so now I've, I have to protect myself with my students, letting them not know who I am. Okay. That's that I can do. I'll bring in examples from both sides.
They're going to be watching a video from the Enemies Project, which is, you know, of their choice and they're going to see multiple sides presented, you know, which is another kind of bridge building space that people, people are, you know, in. But so I can I can figure out how to do this in the classroom. But every single thing that I say on a podcast, on our new TV show that we have that's on the PBS affiliated station, I don't know how that's going to impact me, and I'm really glad. [00:26:54:06] Wilk Wilkinson: I'm glad.
[00:26:54:19] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah, I, I'm really kind of glad I'm close to retirement. And my students can also record my videos in class or I, because I have some students that are online and I have a face to face class. And so I don't know where those videos are going to land. Sure, you another unlisted YouTube videos right now, but, what if somebody sends one to somebody that thinks, oh, she based on what she just said in class today or that clip, she needs to be fired as a professor.
That's hard. [00:27:26:03] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah. No, it's very difficult. And, you know, I'm very grateful now because I was in the corporate world for a long time.
while I was doing this, but before I came on board full time at Brave Angels and. And. Yeah, you're always wondering, you know, is it is has something I said. Going to land because I've obviously been in my more than my share of a very controversial conversations.
I was a guest on the enemies project, so I don't know if what episode that your, your students are going to be watching, but I was on the enemies project with Larry Rosen, and a state rep from the state of Minnesota here. But yeah, going back and I'll have you dig a dig a bit deeper into this April, because that idea of not being read enough in a red state it's I think that's interesting because I, I'm about as conservative, like a real conservative, not like a lot of the conservative people that claim to be conservative today. I'm about as conservative as you can get. But it's very strange because every week I'll end up getting some feedback where I'm either, you know, somebody accuses me as being a liberal that goes by conservative or I'll get I'll, I'll be accused of being a, you know, a super conservative that's just placating to liberals.
I get that, all that stuff. And I'm sure you do to talk a little bit more about that and how when, when you're negotiating that, that institutional and, and political tension, what does that look like for you? [00:29:08:11] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. So, It it comes in many different ways.
You know, one thing is, is that I just end up not having my department associated or my university affiliation associated with my Brave Angels task. And yet I applied for a service award that involved so much of my Angel stuff. And I got the service award from the university. And so it's not like they don't recognize things and they don't appreciate it.
But, there's a lot of fear these days. Wilke and I, I even I'm a department chair in my, my current department, and I would say most of my faculty, if not all of them are, would consider themselves to be progressive. And, and so when I come out also and they maybe watch one of my, my episodes or listen and they hear me say I'm conservative. I also am worried about, well, are they going to think, how am I?
How am I going to be as a as a boss for them? Right. Yeah. And then I know my students could put, you know, potentially watch those and then find out where I stand to.
Doesn't say who I'm going to vote for necessarily because I always vote for the candidate, not for the party. And so, which some people may, may say, well, that doesn't make you truly conservative. So you do get questioned, right? Yeah.
No. And so, I, I do think that how we label ourselves to me, it's more important how a person chooses to describe themselves than it is how how another person describes them. [00:30:50:07] Wilk Wilkinson: Sure, that's great, but that. [00:30:52:13] April Chatham-Carpenter: Doesn't mean that you don't get criticized as you were talking about that.
You do. And that was what my my initial dean that now she's at another university said to me, she's like, April, you think this, but you're never going to be what they want you to be. That's right. And so if I can be truly my whole person, I bring my whole person into this.
But I have to make choices every time I'm even on the television show that that Glenn and I are doing. And I know you're a guest on that as well, have been. And so it is. There are times in which I'm like, okay, I got I got to play the conservative role here.
And so I'm going to push back on Glenn some. And even then how I push back, I want to represent good communication skills or the braver way we would call it in braver angels. And yet there are times even then that I'm teasing or I'm kind of pushing back or playing with him, and he will say during a break, April, that was too much. And I'm like, I'm just trying to make this interesting for the audience.
Yeah. So, you know, playing to your audience, whoever that audience is, is something that we learn to do in media, right, that we learn to do in, in entertainment, that we learn to do, I suppose in education as well. You want your, your students to learn and like you and so but you also want to be true to yourself. Yeah.
So at some point, I mean, sometimes I'm, you know, even sitting in church and I'm just like, okay, so what they just said from the pulpit, do I need to do I need to confront because I don't really agree with that? Or do I just sit and just like, okay, well, it doesn't affect me personally, so I'll just not choose to say anything because I want to maintain my respectability. So it's hard. [00:33:03:17] Wilk Wilkinson: Yeah.
I don't know if I really. [00:33:04:23] April Chatham-Carpenter: Answered your question though. [00:33:06:04] Wilk Wilkinson: Well, I don't know, but everything you said landed well, I mean, it's a it's a it's a very important what you're saying. And it I think the biggest thing that I'm taking away from that particular part of this conversation, April, is, is that it's not always about how others perceive you, but how you perceive yourself and then being true to yourself.
You know, at Braver Angels, part of the Braver angels way that we really promote is getting up there, speaking freely, fully and without fear. And, and then treating each other with respect. We can't control what somebody is going to say about us or what somebody's going to think about us. But you know, like I said, I, I've, I've been I've been accused so many times of, of not being a conservative because modern this modern kind of post liberalism or illiberal populism, whatever you want to call it.
Now, that I may not necessarily see as conservatives, but they, they define it as conservatism is not what I consider traditional conservatism. So so there's an impasse there. Right. And but the reality is, is, is I know what I am and I know who I am and I know what I believe.
And and as long as I'm true to myself in April, as long as you're true to yourself, we get up there, speak freely, fully, without fear. That's great. A citizenship, right? And, and when we're having these conversations, going back to the idea of your paper.
Right. Role multiplicity in practice, we have to play different roles. Sometimes we have to. We have to keep ourselves in check and and listen when when it might be more convenient for us just to just to jump in and and and talk our way and and, again, going back to the idea that you talked about earlier is, you know, the, you know, just because we we hold back what we are about doesn't mean we're neutral or doesn't mean we don't care about what's being talked about.
But sometimes it just takes that to the to be part of a, an effective back and forth and an effective, conversation. April. We've we've definitely gone. Right to the end of our time here.
Probably a little bit over. I'm sure you and I could go on for for a very long time. But how do people find these papers? where can people find the the papers from our our civic scholars council.
I know, I know there's there's ways to get them on Substack. We're going to obviously link to them in the show notes here on the Derate The Hate website. [00:35:46:21] April Chatham-Carpenter: Yeah. So if people will actually go to the Braver Angels website.
There is a under the what we do there is a Civic Scholars Council link there and it actually has the library there. It's says CSC library papers on courageous citizenship, and it defines what the Civic Scholars Council is as well, and tells who the co-chairs are. And and so yeah, people can find a lot of information there, but that's their that's actually on the page now they're, they're publishing them in this I guess it's like a Substack as well too, but it can count as a publication for us as, as scholars then, and a publication called A Beyond Intractability. The word intractability means really difficult conflicts.
So if we're going beyond intractability, we're actually working on constructively handling these difficult conflicts. And so that's what it links out to. My paper was one of the first groups that was actually, published there. And I think the rest of them are coming soon if they're not already there.
[00:36:55:13] Wilk Wilkinson: Very good. We'll make sure those links are in the show notes. People can find them there, and then they can always go to BraverAngels.org but yeah, beyond intractability, it's a there's a Substack and a newsletter, and it's just great to great that they're helping us get these, get these papers published. April Chatham carpenter.
It's been a real pleasure. I've very much enjoyed it, and we'll look forward to the next conversation. [00:37:21:12] April Chatham-Carpenter: Thanks for all you're doing for having me on today. [00:37:24:12] Wilk Wilkinson: Friends, I want to thank you so much for tuning in.
And if there's anything in this episode that provided exceptional value to you, please make sure to hit that share button. If you haven't done so already, please be sure to subscribe to get the Derate The Hate podcast sent to your email inbox every week. We really are better together. So please take a moment to visit Braver angels.org and consider joining the movement towards civic renewal and bridging our political divides.
This is Wilk wrapping up for the week saying get out there. Be kind to one another. Be grateful for everything you've got. And remember, it's up to you to make every day the day that you want it to be.
With that, my friend, I'm going to back on out of here and we will catch you next week. Take care.
Comments & Upvotes