Send Wilk a text with your feedback!
Courageous Connections: Embracing Pluralism Amidst American Populism
In this Derate The Hate bonus episode, host Wilk Wilkinson sits down with fellow Braver Angels Ibrahim Anli and Will Harwood for a powerful discussion on cultural and religious pluralism in the face of American populism.
They explore what it means to be American in today’s polarized climate and the importance of courageous connections in embracing diversity. Ibrahim, an immigrant to the U.S., and Will, a native-born American, share their personal insights on how America’s evolving identity can remain rooted in foundational civic values while allowing room for pluralism.
Key Topics:
Featured Guests:
Takeaways:
Listen Now to hear a thought-provoking conversation on how we can embrace diversity, overcome polarization, and strengthen the fabric of American society in the face of modern challenges.
The world is a better place if we are better people. That begins with each of us as individuals. Be kind to one another. Be grateful for all you’ve got. Make every day the day that you want it to be!
Please follow The Derate The Hate podcast on:
Facebook, Instagram, Twitter(X) , YouTube
Subscribe to us wherever you enjoy your audio or from our site. Please leave us a rating and feedback on Apple podcasts or other platforms. You can share your thoughts or request Wilk for a speaking engagement on our contact page: DerateTheHate.com/Contact
The Derate The Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels — America’s largest grassroots, cross-partisan organization working toward civic renewal and bridging partisan divides. Learn more: BraverAngels.org
Welcome to the Derate The Hate Podcast!
*The views expressed by Wilk, his guest hosts &/or guests on the Derate The Hate podcast are their own and should not be attributed to any organization they may otherwise be affiliated with.
Transcript is AI generated and may contain errors
00:00:00:00 - 00:00:32:03
Wilk Wilkinson
Do you ever feel uneasy about the changes happening in our society today? Are you concerned or maybe even fearful about how immigration, cultural pluralism and religious diversity are reshaping the very fabric of our national identity? Americanization means the process of becoming an American. It means civic incorporation, becoming a part of the polity, becoming one of us. But that does not mean conformity.
00:00:32:05 - 00:00:59:11
Wilk Wilkinson
We are more than a melting pot. We are a kaleidoscope. This is a quote from Barbara Jordan, civil rights icon and constitutional scholar, and it reminds us that being an American isn't about sameness. It's about shared purpose. It's about civic belonging. And it's about embracing the vibrant, refracted diversity that makes this country not just a place, but a promise.
00:00:59:12 - 00:01:20:04
Wilk Wilkinson
In today's episode, I am joined by two fellow braver angels. Will Harwood and Ibrahim Anli for a powerful conversation about civic culture, national identity and what it means to choose America not just as a home, but as a story we live into together.
00:01:20:04 - 00:01:23:13
Ibrahim Anli
it was this living contract. And I'll quote,
00:01:23:13 - 00:01:41:02
Ibrahim Anli
Alexis de Tocqueville, maybe not in an exact word form, but he says the the greatest strength of Americans is their ability and willingness to to face their shortcomings, to encounter their shortcomings.
00:01:41:04 - 00:01:42:21
Ibrahim Anli
That is being just,
00:01:42:21 - 00:01:44:05
Ibrahim Anli
such,
00:01:44:05 - 00:01:47:00
Ibrahim Anli
a profound part of this
00:01:47:00 - 00:01:49:00
Will Harwood
I think that there's a fundamental,
00:01:49:00 - 00:01:56:10
Will Harwood
optimism and sense of we rise to our challenges, whatever those are, as a country, and we find our way through.
00:01:56:12 - 00:01:57:07
Will Harwood
And,
00:01:57:07 - 00:02:05:13
Will Harwood
to me, that is a that's a fundamental American spirit, right? Like we're going to be able to get through whatever the challenges are. Now, today with polarization, I always say,
00:02:05:13 - 00:02:12:05
Will Harwood
we don't we don't choose. No American generation has ever sat down and chosen the challenges that it's confronting.
00:02:12:06 - 00:02:14:00
Will Harwood
But always we've risen to them.
00:02:14:00 - 00:02:16:11
Ibrahim Anli
it's it's just the story of,
00:02:16:11 - 00:02:30:08
Ibrahim Anli
another individual who, as you said, chooses this country to as as his home and to a very large number of countries in the world.
00:02:30:10 - 00:02:32:12
Ibrahim Anli
This whole idea of,
00:02:32:12 - 00:02:44:02
Ibrahim Anli
adopting that country as your home is a lot of technicalities. It's a matter of technicalities. It's not a matter of story or identity.
00:02:44:02 - 00:02:47:05
Ibrahim Anli
Even if that happens, that that happens in,
00:02:47:05 - 00:02:55:12
Ibrahim Anli
multiple generations. Not in the case of the United States. It is this living contract,
00:02:55:12 - 00:02:57:18
Ibrahim Anli
way beyond technicalities,
00:02:57:18 - 00:03:05:19
Will Harwood
I think part of the challenge that we have to do today is also ground ourselves so that we have that shared understanding of what the civic culture needs to be,
00:03:05:19 - 00:03:07:13
Will Harwood
and how we can set that forward.
00:03:07:13 - 00:03:40:13
Wilk Wilkinson
Two Americans, one natural born, one by choice. Different backgrounds and beliefs. Coming together for a conversation about optimism, realism and the living contract we all share as citizens. It's about grounding ourselves in civic culture, not as nostalgia, but as a forward looking foundation. So whether you're feeling hopeful or uncertain, this discussion is for you. Let's roll that intro and get into this bonus episode.
00:03:40:13 - 00:04:29:22
Wilk Wilkinson
Welcome back, my friends, for the Derate The Hate podcast. I'm your host, Wilk Wilkinson, your blue collar sage calming outrage and helping to navigate a world divided by fog. And those who would spread that fear, outrage and grievance. The Derate the Hate podcast is proudly produced in collaboration with Braver Angels, America's largest grassroots cross Partizan organization working towards civic renewal.
00:04:30:00 - 00:04:57:04
Wilk Wilkinson
This podcast amplifies the mission that we share to foster a more respectful and united America where civic friendship thrives even when we disagree. Each week, through the power of story, conversation, and connection with incredible guests, we work to build bridges instead of barriers, not to change minds on the issues, but to change how we see one another when we differ.
00:04:57:06 - 00:05:21:13
Wilk Wilkinson
Because friends, it really is about bettering the world one attitude at a time. We did not create the hate, but together we can Derate The Hate. So be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcast. Share it with a friend and visit Braver angels.org to learn how you can get involved in the movement to bridge the partizan divide.
00:05:21:15 - 00:05:30:09
Wilk Wilkinson
Friends, I am so incredibly grateful that you have joined me for another powerful Derate The Hate episode. So let's get to it.
00:05:31:04 - 00:06:13:00
Wilk Wilkinson
In today's conversation. Ibrahim Anli and Will Harwood discuss the complex balance between religious and cultural pluralism and American identity, particularly in this populist era. Ibrahim, as an immigrant, reflects on the concept of a living contract, an evolving civic creed that transcends legalities, reminding us that America's strength lies in its ability to self-correct and adapt. He emphasizes that America's unique power lies in its openness to newcomers, allowing for personal and religious freedom, a space where immigrants like him can find both refuge and opportunity.
00:06:13:02 - 00:06:39:03
Wilk Wilkinson
Will builds on this by underscoring the importance of grounding ourselves in the nation's founding principles, especially the Constitution. He points to the ongoing challenges of polarization and skepticism, but encourages an optimistic outlook rooted in historic resilience, reminding us that America's greatness is defined by its ability to confront adversity through open conversation.
00:06:39:03 - 00:06:48:08
Wilk Wilkinson
Together, Ibrahim and will highlight that embracing both cultural pluralism and a shared commitment to foundational values is
00:06:48:12 - 00:06:51:15
Wilk Wilkinson
The key to overcoming division and ensuring
00:06:51:15 - 00:06:59:06
Wilk Wilkinson
the American experiment continues to thrive. Let's get into it with my friends, Will and Ibrahim! Here we go.
00:06:59:06 - 00:07:00:11
Wilk Wilkinson
Ibrahim,
00:07:00:11 - 00:07:01:14
Wilk Wilkinson
Anli and,
00:07:01:14 - 00:07:09:23
Wilk Wilkinson
Will Harwood, thank you so much for joining me for this special episode of the Derate The Hate podcast. I appreciate you guys being here today.
00:07:10:01 - 00:07:11:12
Ibrahim Anli
Thank you. Happy to be here.
00:07:11:14 - 00:07:13:21
Will Harwood
Great to be with you guys.
00:07:13:23 - 00:07:17:05
Wilk Wilkinson
Yeah. So so excited for this conversation.
00:07:17:05 - 00:07:22:00
Wilk Wilkinson
you guys have both been part of Braver Angels for for a while now,
00:07:22:00 - 00:07:35:09
Wilk Wilkinson
and know how important it is to have these, these wonderful conversations freely, fully without fear and and. Will, when you came to me with the idea that that,
00:07:35:09 - 00:07:48:07
Wilk Wilkinson
that there was a relationship that you had been building with Ibrahim and, and on and then this topic of, religious pluralism and, and how that worked with,
00:07:48:07 - 00:07:54:00
Wilk Wilkinson
American identity and in this, this kind of populist era.
00:07:54:02 - 00:08:03:14
Wilk Wilkinson
It just it was such an interesting idea, and I thought it was such an important concept that we should bring this, this conversation.
00:08:03:14 - 00:08:05:07
Wilk Wilkinson
Between the two of you,
00:08:05:07 - 00:08:17:01
Wilk Wilkinson
to the listeners, because because this is one of those conversations and one of those things that I think is on a lot of people's minds, especially today in this, in this era that we're in.
00:08:17:03 - 00:08:17:15
Wilk Wilkinson
And,
00:08:17:15 - 00:08:23:18
Wilk Wilkinson
for the two of you to step up and be willing to, to have that that conversation,
00:08:23:18 - 00:08:29:19
Wilk Wilkinson
right now is, is is incredible. So thank you both very much for,
00:08:29:19 - 00:08:32:07
Wilk Wilkinson
for being here today.
00:08:32:09 - 00:08:37:03
Will Harwood
Absolutely. Yeah. Thank you, Wilk, for having us. It's really I'm excited for the conversation.
00:08:37:03 - 00:08:39:04
Will Harwood
That we can jump into. And I'll just say,
00:08:39:04 - 00:08:39:20
Will Harwood
when I,
00:08:39:20 - 00:08:50:21
Will Harwood
Ibrahim and I were talking about this originally, one of the things that I love so much about Braver Angels is that it brings you together with really great Americans, people that are looking to build,
00:08:50:21 - 00:08:51:18
Will Harwood
and to,
00:08:51:18 - 00:08:58:08
Will Harwood
take on the challenge of polarization to restart the conversations, to engage, to get together.
00:08:58:10 - 00:08:59:17
Will Harwood
And, Ibrahim,
00:08:59:17 - 00:09:01:15
Will Harwood
from the first moment that I met him,
00:09:01:15 - 00:09:05:20
Will Harwood
has always struck me in, the meetings where
00:09:05:20 - 00:09:08:19
Will Harwood
I walk away and I leave with thoughts,
00:09:08:19 - 00:09:11:06
Will Harwood
that are provoking and,
00:09:11:06 - 00:09:12:22
Will Harwood
things that stick with me,
00:09:12:22 - 00:09:16:12
Will Harwood
so I can go back all the way through, probably to the first time, Ibrahim, that you and I met.
00:09:16:17 - 00:09:19:04
Will Harwood
And I can recount the,
00:09:19:04 - 00:09:22:07
Will Harwood
pieces of of insight that you've shared.
00:09:22:07 - 00:09:23:14
Will Harwood
So rich and,
00:09:23:14 - 00:09:27:16
Will Harwood
obviously we come. We're all coming together as Americans first and foremost.
00:09:27:16 - 00:09:31:14
Will Harwood
And but we all come with our own unique backgrounds and stories.
00:09:31:14 - 00:09:39:03
Will Harwood
But this, this topic of American identity, to me, is sort of the fundamental question today,
00:09:39:03 - 00:09:40:23
Will Harwood
of what it is that defines us.
00:09:40:23 - 00:09:42:17
Will Harwood
And if you just look at the,
00:09:42:17 - 00:09:44:12
Will Harwood
the past couple of weeks,
00:09:44:12 - 00:09:49:20
Will Harwood
the vice president, J.D. Vance, I don't know if you saw his speech at the Claremont Institute,
00:09:49:20 - 00:09:54:21
Will Harwood
recently, but it was really centered on these exact topics. I was just looking at that up,
00:09:54:21 - 00:10:01:00
Will Harwood
in preparation for this, this call. But he was putting forward a lot of the same kind of core,
00:10:01:00 - 00:10:03:12
Will Harwood
concepts of how do we deal with,
00:10:03:12 - 00:10:06:10
Will Harwood
cultural diversity and also,
00:10:06:10 - 00:10:14:02
Will Harwood
religious diversity, cultural diversity, but also having that shared sense of what it means to be American and making sure that our identity can be,
00:10:14:02 - 00:10:14:22
Will Harwood
above that,
00:10:14:22 - 00:10:15:09
Will Harwood
at the higher
00:10:15:09 - 00:10:20:19
Will Harwood
level in a, in a respect. So I'm really thrilled to to join you guys for this conversation.
00:10:20:21 - 00:10:23:04
Wilk Wilkinson
Yeah. Me too. So, so, Ibrahim,
00:10:23:04 - 00:10:27:17
Wilk Wilkinson
let let me let me ask you then, then right off the bat because,
00:10:27:17 - 00:10:28:08
Wilk Wilkinson
I know,
00:10:28:08 - 00:10:30:06
Wilk Wilkinson
both Will and I were born,
00:10:30:06 - 00:10:34:23
Wilk Wilkinson
born here, native to the United States. But you are,
00:10:34:23 - 00:10:47:20
Wilk Wilkinson
you you are somebody who immigrated to the United States. So when when people talk about the American identity and and what the American identity is and and,
00:10:47:20 - 00:10:55:20
Wilk Wilkinson
what does that mean to you as somebody who, who, who chose to come here and chose to make that,
00:10:55:20 - 00:10:59:00
Wilk Wilkinson
part of a part of your life because,
00:10:59:00 - 00:11:03:20
Wilk Wilkinson
I think there's obviously a, a, a paradox there,
00:11:03:20 - 00:11:04:09
Wilk Wilkinson
that, that a
00:11:04:09 - 00:11:14:14
Wilk Wilkinson
lot of people don't quite understand. Yes, we are all Americans. Well, and I by birth, you by choice. So talk to me about,
00:11:14:14 - 00:11:21:22
Wilk Wilkinson
about the American identity and what that means to you and why that is so important to you.
00:11:22:00 - 00:11:23:04
Ibrahim Anli
Yeah. Thank you. And,
00:11:23:04 - 00:11:32:21
Ibrahim Anli
just a note of of gratitude and acknowledgment of two braver angels, which has truly been this welcoming,
00:11:32:21 - 00:11:43:04
Ibrahim Anli
not only welcoming, but really well functioning home at that, at this moment of intense effort to to retell
00:11:43:04 - 00:11:59:17
Ibrahim Anli
the story of this country and who we are and what as a country, as a society, we have stood for and we should be standing for moving forward, what we want to leave to our children and and more particularly into my story.
00:11:59:19 - 00:12:04:17
Ibrahim Anli
Yes, I was born and raised overseas and spent my formative years,
00:12:04:17 - 00:12:16:19
Ibrahim Anli
away from the US. Though I was always very closely exposed because I was fortunate to have a large cohort of American teachers at my school.
00:12:16:19 - 00:12:30:05
Ibrahim Anli
And as a teenager and, and after those years, basically, I don't think I had any, any week without something connected to or from or related to,
00:12:30:05 - 00:12:33:14
Ibrahim Anli
United States in my professional role as,
00:12:33:14 - 00:12:37:03
Ibrahim Anli
as in nonprofit work and frequently,
00:12:37:03 - 00:12:39:08
Ibrahim Anli
visiting the US and also,
00:12:39:08 - 00:12:41:06
Ibrahim Anli
studying here in the past,
00:12:41:06 - 00:12:43:02
Ibrahim Anli
as an international student.
00:12:43:04 - 00:12:43:22
Ibrahim Anli
But,
00:12:43:22 - 00:12:45:21
Ibrahim Anli
this story is,
00:12:45:21 - 00:12:56:13
Ibrahim Anli
unique. So it's like fingers. They're all fingers, but they have all their unique fingerprints. I think my story is one. So it's it's just the story of,
00:12:56:13 - 00:13:10:10
Ibrahim Anli
another individual who, as you said, chooses this country to as as his home and to a very large number of countries in the world.
00:13:10:12 - 00:13:12:14
Ibrahim Anli
This whole idea of,
00:13:12:14 - 00:13:24:04
Ibrahim Anli
adopting that country as your home is a lot of technicalities. It's a matter of technicalities. It's not a matter of story or identity.
00:13:24:04 - 00:13:27:07
Ibrahim Anli
Even if that happens, that that happens in,
00:13:27:07 - 00:13:35:14
Ibrahim Anli
multiple generations. Not in the case of the United States. It is this living contract,
00:13:35:14 - 00:13:37:21
Ibrahim Anli
way beyond technicalities,
00:13:37:21 - 00:13:45:22
Ibrahim Anli
and, that you choose to be part of, to uphold and to, to, to and you believe it.
00:13:46:00 - 00:13:55:19
Ibrahim Anli
So, and as a, as a reference to our larger conversations nowadays, that's one reason that,
00:13:55:19 - 00:13:58:02
Ibrahim Anli
immigration is, is,
00:13:58:02 - 00:14:11:21
Ibrahim Anli
part of the strength, the drive, the, the, the wonderful story of this country. And it's because of its such unique role. It has been part of the challenge. So that's again,
00:14:11:21 - 00:14:14:23
Ibrahim Anli
quite specific to very few countries.
00:14:15:01 - 00:14:20:13
Ibrahim Anli
And to me, it means being part of this,
00:14:20:13 - 00:14:24:12
Ibrahim Anli
wider contract. Some part of it is,
00:14:24:12 - 00:14:30:12
Ibrahim Anli
is codified, such as the Constitution and some other parts of it is,
00:14:30:12 - 00:14:37:03
Ibrahim Anli
is a is a civic creed. That's how I would put it. And
00:14:37:03 - 00:14:43:23
Ibrahim Anli
Braver Angels, for example, has been very successful because it is helping people.
00:14:43:23 - 00:14:52:19
Ibrahim Anli
During this time of maybe soul searching, reconnect with that whole idea of civic creed, of who we are.
00:14:52:21 - 00:14:53:08
Wilk Wilkinson
Yeah.
00:14:53:08 - 00:14:55:22
Wilk Wilkinson
so talk to me then a little bit more,
00:14:55:22 - 00:14:57:09
Wilk Wilkinson
about and then I'll, and then I'll get
00:14:57:09 - 00:14:59:12
Wilk Wilkinson
your input on this Will, but
00:14:59:12 - 00:15:01:12
Wilk Wilkinson
talk to me a little bit about,
00:15:01:12 - 00:15:08:05
Wilk Wilkinson
you said a couple of things like civic creed and living contract that that really,
00:15:08:05 - 00:15:10:05
Wilk Wilkinson
I, I would just love to know,
00:15:10:05 - 00:15:13:05
Wilk Wilkinson
when you talk about things like that, what what does that mean?
00:15:13:05 - 00:15:14:14
Wilk Wilkinson
And, and how,
00:15:14:14 - 00:15:15:20
Wilk Wilkinson
what is,
00:15:15:20 - 00:15:17:16
Wilk Wilkinson
what is our responsibility as
00:15:17:16 - 00:15:24:07
Wilk Wilkinson
native born Americans in that? And then what is your responsibility as somebody who's, who's come to this country,
00:15:24:07 - 00:15:27:12
Wilk Wilkinson
to to be part of that?
00:15:27:14 - 00:15:35:20
Ibrahim Anli
Yeah, this, this idea of living contract. Of course, we can have multiple versions of wording it and approaching it, but,
00:15:35:20 - 00:15:46:22
Ibrahim Anli
the, the Founding Fathers, in my understanding, highlighted a vision that in practice was,
00:15:46:22 - 00:15:49:13
Ibrahim Anli
trusted to people to be,
00:15:49:13 - 00:16:01:12
Ibrahim Anli
traveled towards constantly. That's why it's a living contract. It's been reinterpreted and retold almost by every generation.
00:16:01:14 - 00:16:02:02
Ibrahim Anli
And,
00:16:02:02 - 00:16:17:21
Ibrahim Anli
like speaking of Americans religious history, I remember hearing a comment what? It was primarily Protestants who started the country and then those who came and protested them, and those who came afterwards protested them. But,
00:16:17:21 - 00:16:24:07
Ibrahim Anli
speaking of the larger public sphere, it was this living contract. And I'll quote,
00:16:24:07 - 00:16:41:20
Ibrahim Anli
Alexis de Tocqueville, maybe not in an exact word form, but he says the the greatest strength of Americans is their ability and willingness to to face their shortcomings, to encounter their shortcomings.
00:16:41:22 - 00:16:43:15
Ibrahim Anli
That is being just,
00:16:43:15 - 00:16:44:23
Ibrahim Anli
such,
00:16:44:23 - 00:16:50:05
Ibrahim Anli
a profound part of this story. So,
00:16:50:05 - 00:16:56:22
Ibrahim Anli
and and that should also mean if we are talking about a living contract,
00:16:56:22 - 00:17:01:09
Ibrahim Anli
a sense of continuity together with a sense of connection.
00:17:01:09 - 00:17:10:16
Ibrahim Anli
So our our search, in my opinion, should not mean, just adventurous,
00:17:10:16 - 00:17:14:01
Ibrahim Anli
disconnection with, with with the story.
00:17:14:06 - 00:17:22:08
Ibrahim Anli
This is our story. With ups and downs, with moments that we can be proud of and with other moments that we cannot but,
00:17:22:08 - 00:17:23:20
Ibrahim Anli
that's how,
00:17:23:20 - 00:17:28:09
Ibrahim Anli
I think it's, it has evolved and it it should be evolving. Just,
00:17:28:09 - 00:17:33:09
Ibrahim Anli
we should be traveling with this sense of incompleteness.
00:17:33:09 - 00:17:33:20
Ibrahim Anli
And
00:17:33:20 - 00:17:37:01
Ibrahim Anli
which I believe again, has been this,
00:17:37:01 - 00:17:58:15
Ibrahim Anli
productive cycle since the time of the Founding Fathers and, and with, with the living Creed I'm referring to maybe more or less contractual, but more relational parts of it, that the sense of people who that's beyond mechanics and it, it did exist.
00:17:58:17 - 00:18:03:16
Ibrahim Anli
The, this country wouldn't have been around if, hadn't if that didn't exist.
00:18:03:18 - 00:18:08:00
Wilk Wilkinson
Right. Right now and will so so when we think about that,
00:18:08:00 - 00:18:15:01
Wilk Wilkinson
that living contract that, that that America is, is, is a constantly evolving thing. And,
00:18:15:01 - 00:18:17:16
Wilk Wilkinson
we are constantly working through,
00:18:17:16 - 00:18:19:23
Wilk Wilkinson
new challenges or,
00:18:19:23 - 00:18:22:08
Wilk Wilkinson
being willing to,
00:18:22:08 - 00:18:24:07
Wilk Wilkinson
to step up and accept our,
00:18:24:07 - 00:18:25:04
Wilk Wilkinson
our problems
00:18:25:04 - 00:18:27:05
Wilk Wilkinson
and work through those together.
00:18:27:07 - 00:18:33:12
Wilk Wilkinson
And so talk, talk to me a little bit about how you see that in terms of,
00:18:33:12 - 00:18:40:10
Wilk Wilkinson
the civic creed and what we are trying to do here that is, is fairly uniquely American.
00:18:40:12 - 00:18:47:04
Will Harwood
Yeah. I mean, I think just going back to actually something that Ibrahim said, just as we were kind of talking through the idea of this, is that,
00:18:47:04 - 00:18:52:04
Will Harwood
we have to make this work and we do make this work. So I think that there's a fundamental,
00:18:52:04 - 00:18:59:14
Will Harwood
optimism and sense of we rise to our challenges, whatever those are, as a country, and we find our way through.
00:18:59:16 - 00:19:00:11
Will Harwood
And,
00:19:00:11 - 00:19:08:17
Will Harwood
to me, that is a that's a fundamental American spirit, right? Like we're going to be able to get through whatever the challenges are. Now, today with polarization, I always say,
00:19:08:17 - 00:19:15:09
Will Harwood
we don't we don't choose. No American generation has ever sat down and chosen the challenges that it's confronting.
00:19:15:09 - 00:19:17:03
Will Harwood
But always we've risen to them.
00:19:17:03 - 00:19:24:23
Will Harwood
And that goes back to beating the biggest empire in the world for our founders or for at our founding. The revolution to the Civil War,
00:19:24:23 - 00:19:26:02
Will Harwood
and to the,
00:19:26:02 - 00:19:32:08
Will Harwood
the defining wars of the 20th century and every other social movement that's come through. We find our way through,
00:19:32:08 - 00:19:38:11
Will Harwood
and I think that that is a kind of an attitude that we have that we have to maintain and, and,
00:19:38:11 - 00:19:41:22
Will Harwood
and making sure that we can find the productive ways to do that.
00:19:41:22 - 00:19:53:00
Will Harwood
The way we have to do that is to talk to each other and to be able to have these direct conversations about important topics that we're able to chart the right course. But,
00:19:53:00 - 00:19:55:03
Will Harwood
when I think about, well, the,
00:19:55:03 - 00:20:00:12
Will Harwood
this question of, of American civics and,
00:20:00:12 - 00:20:08:09
Will Harwood
the civic contract that we have and then also the founding ideals of the country with the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence.
00:20:08:11 - 00:20:18:15
Will Harwood
Those are ones where to me, when I when we talk about our challenges, I think that one of our greatest challenges is that we're not as grounded in those as we need to be. We don't have as much of a sense of,
00:20:18:15 - 00:20:20:12
Will Harwood
that that grounding,
00:20:20:12 - 00:20:22:20
Will Harwood
civic education, if you will.
00:20:22:20 - 00:20:34:13
Will Harwood
That allows us to be confident in what we are and when you when you lack of confidence from that knowledge, I think it can be things can go off the rails.
00:20:34:13 - 00:20:42:18
Will Harwood
So I think part of the challenge that we have to do today is also ground ourselves so that we have that shared understanding of what the civic culture needs to be,
00:20:42:18 - 00:20:44:20
Will Harwood
and how we can set that forward.
00:20:44:20 - 00:20:46:19
Will Harwood
And to me that,
00:20:46:19 - 00:20:52:11
Will Harwood
that's part of this conversation here is that we all need to reassert and engage as much as we can,
00:20:52:11 - 00:21:01:03
Will Harwood
to help us unpack that so we can come to that shared understanding of what what American civic obligations are that we have and so forth.
00:21:01:03 - 00:21:04:01
Wilk Wilkinson
So so I have a question for both of you then. So,
00:21:04:01 - 00:21:11:13
Wilk Wilkinson
when we think about those, those obligations and what we as, as Americans,
00:21:11:13 - 00:21:18:05
Wilk Wilkinson
which I think we all agree this, this thing that we have in America is, is pretty unique to the United States of America.
00:21:18:05 - 00:21:24:17
Wilk Wilkinson
so when we think about those things, what are our obligations then?
00:21:24:17 - 00:21:26:03
Wilk Wilkinson
And I'll start with you,
00:21:26:03 - 00:21:28:21
Wilk Wilkinson
Will, when we,
00:21:28:21 - 00:21:33:16
Wilk Wilkinson
we see that a lot of times today,
00:21:33:16 - 00:21:34:21
Wilk Wilkinson
especially in,
00:21:34:21 - 00:21:43:01
Wilk Wilkinson
in the more populist era and the things where, where our politics seem to go by the whims of whoever seems to be in office at the time,
00:21:43:01 - 00:21:48:21
Wilk Wilkinson
what are our obligations as a citizen when it comes to the civic creed, the
00:21:48:21 - 00:21:51:21
Wilk Wilkinson
civic contract?
00:21:51:23 - 00:21:58:07
Wilk Wilkinson
Just we'll talk about that real quick for me. And then I want to turn that question over to Ibrahim.
00:21:58:09 - 00:22:20:07
Will Harwood
So I think that we need to keep a focus on we all have our own personal stories and our personal identities, which are unique to us like nobody else. Just as Ibrahim said, it's a fingerprint. We're each our own fingerprint. And that goes back to our stories, our families, our histories. How we got to where we are and we,
00:22:20:07 - 00:22:21:10
Will Harwood
take pride in those.
00:22:21:10 - 00:22:24:11
Will Harwood
That's that's integral to our identity.
00:22:24:11 - 00:
Comments & Upvotes